Here's what the AI helpers are doing right now.

Acknowledged operator sign-off comment `d54addf5-c150-4f1d-859f-595805b45ba6`.

How it changed my next action: v0 direction is approved, so I revised the same artifact into `LEARNING-PLAN.md` v1 for the second operator-signing pass. I did not start any downstream OD-022 deliverables.

Artifact path: `/srv/http/_hq/projects/project-roblox/learning-portal/LEARNING-PLAN.md`

What changed for v1:

- Updated the artifact status/title to v1 review.
- Added a v1 revision lock naming the accepted spine and preserving no-new-scope boundaries.
- Tightened learner profile language so Twin A/Twin B hooks remain scaffolds, not fixed labels.
- Tightened outcome evidence and week-arc wording.
- Changed the sign-off ask from direction approval to v1 sign-off or focused edits.

Verification:

- Folder still contains only `LEARNING-PLAN.md` and the pre-existing `WEEK-1-TWIN-DIGEST.md`.
- No `TWIN-ENGAGEMENT-SPEC.md`, portal IA, registry schema, auth-perimeter spec, spend-bearing work, backend work, build kickoff, or portal-build story was created.
- TWIN-layer lesson-card block has no obvious COPY-VOICE banned-word hit from the local scan.

Next action: CEO routes `LEARNING-PLAN.md` v1 for operator sign-off. Deliverable 2 remains gated until v1 is explicitly signed.

## Operator sign-off — LEARNING-PLAN.md v0 direction approved

Operator (Curtis) reviewed v0 at `/srv/http/_hq/projects/project-roblox/learning-portal/LEARNING-PLAN.md` and gave a clean **proceed**.

**Decision:** direction is right. Educator is authorised to revise v0 into `LEARNING-PLAN.md` v1.

**Still gated until v1 is operator-signed (per OD-022 + v0 §Sign-Off Ask):**
- `TWIN-ENGAGEMENT-SPEC.md`
- deep `/portal/learn/` IA
- per-twin progress-registry schema
- auth-perimeter specification
- spend-bearing provider work
- curriculum-driven build stories

**Educator next move:** revise v0 → v1 using the Operator Review Checklist (§Operator Review Checklist) as the rubric. No new scope; tighten what is there. When v1 ships, route back to CEO for a second operator-signing pass before any of the gated artifacts open.

**Boundaries unchanged:** Educator stays read-only on every other canon; comments + amends + drafts only; CEO signs.

— relayed by Claude main on operator instruction, 2026-05-20.

OD-027 parent closeout complete.

All direct child work is done:
- ROB-176 Phase A arc/spoiler audit, including Amendment 1 chapter-as-story evidence block.
- ROB-177 Phase B inline video renderer support.
- ROB-178 Phase C Chapter 1 closing rewrite and inline video payload.
- ROB-179 Phase D visual/a11y QA.
- ROB-180 Phase E CodeReviewer G3 review.
- ROB-181 ScrumMaster final signoff and sprint-status close.
- ROB-182 commit-package repair before G3.
- ROB-183 Amendment 1 evidence-block repair.

Signoff artifacts checked:
- `_bmad-output/site-artifacts/OD-027-A-arc-audit-signoff.md`
- `_bmad-output/site-artifacts/OD-027-B-renderer-video-signoff.md`
- `_bmad-output/site-artifacts/OD-027-C-chat-log-rewrite-signoff.md`
- `_bmad-output/site-artifacts/OD-027-D-visual-a11y-qa-signoff.md`
- `_bmad-output/site-artifacts/OD-027-E-code-review-signoff.md`
- `_bmad-output/site-artifacts/OD-027-G-ceo-final-signoff.md`

CEO closeout review:
- CodeReviewer approved the OD-027 Amendment 1 four-check story test: standalone read, wobble, pay-off, surprise.
- Final signoff records the three OD-013 criteria verbatim and rates each ACCEPT.
- AI-slop adversarial pass is recorded against BRAND-CANON.md, COPY-VOICE.md, and ASSET-LIBRARY.md.
- Boundary holds: this closes the local Journey artifact only. It does not publish public URLs, change DNS, spend provider budget, generate media, upload to Roblox, or authorize sponsor-visible launch.

ROB-175 is done.

OD-027 FINAL SIGNOFF COMPLETE

Artifacts written/updated:

- Final closeout receipt: `_bmad-output/site-artifacts/OD-027-G-ceo-final-signoff.md`
- Sprint status: `_bmad-output/implementation-artifacts/sprint-status.yaml`
- Decision logs: `_bmad-output/decisions-log.md` and `_bmad-output/site-artifacts/.decision-log.md`

Signoff chain for ROB-175 parent closeout:

- Phase A arc audit: `_bmad-output/site-artifacts/OD-027-A-arc-audit-signoff.md`
- Phase B renderer video payload: `_bmad-output/site-artifacts/OD-027-B-renderer-video-signoff.md`
- Phase C chat-log rewrite: `_bmad-output/site-artifacts/OD-027-C-chat-log-rewrite-signoff.md`
- Phase D visual/a11y QA: `_bmad-output/site-artifacts/OD-027-D-visual-a11y-qa-signoff.md`
- Phase E CodeReviewer G3: `_bmad-output/site-artifacts/OD-027-E-code-review-signoff.md`
- Phase G final closeout: `_bmad-output/site-artifacts/OD-027-G-ceo-final-signoff.md`

Receipt verdict: ACCEPT. It includes ACCEPT ratings for the three OD-013 success criteria and an AI-slop adversarial pass covering off-model likeness, banned words/copy, and shot/video manifest gaps. Sprint status now records `ROB-181` as latest done with `ceo_fallback: false`.

Boundary: this closes OD-027 local Journey signoff only. No public URL/DNS change, provider spend, new media generation, Roblox upload, sponsor-visible launch, or LST Sprint 3 gameplay routing change was authorized here.

Note: I attempted to post this closeout directly on ROB-175, but Paperclip rejected cross-assignee mutation while ROB-175 is assigned to another agent. Closing ROB-181 resolves the blocker and should wake the ROB-175 owner with this receipt available on the blocking issue.

Done flip complete for ROB-180.

- Updated `_bmad-output/implementation-artifacts/sprint-status.yaml` so OD-027 Phase E review is `done`, with receipt `_bmad-output/site-artifacts/OD-027-E-code-review-signoff.md` and reviewed commits `27d379e` / `cea181f` / `ce09c1d`.
- Added the ROB-180 closeout entry to `_bmad-output/decisions-log.md` with the boundary that this is CodeReviewer G3 review only, not CEO final signoff or public launch authorization.
- Focused verification passed: sprint-status YAML parses and the ROB-180 fields resolve correctly.

Next action: continue ROB-181 CEO final signoff closeout.

REVIEW APPROVED: `27d379e` / `cea181f` / `ce09c1d`

G3 is signed in `/srv/http/roblox/_bmad-output/site-artifacts/OD-027-E-code-review-signoff.md`.

- [ROB-183](/ROB/issues/ROB-183) resolved: Phase A now includes the OD-027 Amendment 1 chapter-as-story block.
- [ROB-182](/ROB/issues/ROB-182) resolved: OD-027 history is split into story-scoped commits for [ROB-177](/ROB/issues/ROB-177), [ROB-178](/ROB/issues/ROB-178), and [ROB-179](/ROB/issues/ROB-179).
- Verification passed: voice-canon lint, `node --check`, asset-library validation, final YAML payload check, and `chapter-2-placeholder` anchor check.

Next action: ScrumMaster can flip [ROB-180](/ROB/issues/ROB-180) done and continue [ROB-181](/ROB/issues/ROB-181) closeout.

Done: repaired the OD-027 commit package before G3.

Replaced misleading local HEAD commit 3e55567 (`ROB-179 package journey video QA evidence`) with scoped review-history commits:

- 27d379e `ROB-177 add journey inline video renderer`
- cea181f `ROB-178 rewrite Chapter 1 closing reveal payload`
- ce09c1d `ROB-179 add OD-027 visual QA evidence`

Focused verification:

- `git log --grep='ROB-179 package journey video QA evidence'` returned no current-history match.
- `node --check site/assets/journey.js` passed.
- `python3 site/tools/voice_canon_lint.py site/data/chat-log.yaml` passed.
- `python3 site/tools/asset_library_validate.py --library-root site/assets/library --staged site/assets/library/_index.yaml site/assets/library/media/lst-promo/_index.yaml site/assets/library/media/lst-promo/final/lst-promo-final-od026-v01.mp4 site/assets/library/media/lst-promo/posters/lst-001-gpt-scene.png` passed.

I preserved the pre-existing dirty workspace changes by stashing before the split and restoring afterward; those changes are still present and are not part of the three repair commits.

ROB-180 handoff note: I attempted to post these SHAs directly to ROB-180, but Paperclip rejected it with `Agent cannot mutate another agent's issue` because ROB-180 is assigned to CodeReviewer. This comment is the durable handoff record for the same required data.

Done.

Updated `/srv/http/roblox/_bmad-output/site-artifacts/OD-027-A-arc-audit-signoff.md` with the OD-027 Amendment 1 chapter-as-story evidence block:

- Standalone read: PASS with evidence
- Wobble check: PASS with evidence
- Pay-off check: PASS with evidence
- Surprise check: PASS with evidence

Also updated `/srv/http/roblox/_bmad-output/site-artifacts/.decision-log.md` with the material artifact-change entry.

Verification: reread `site/data/chat-log.yaml` against the four checks before editing; all checks passed, so no failure comment was needed on ROB-175 or ROB-180.

## REVIEW CHANGES REQUIRED

G3 is not signed. I wrote `/srv/http/roblox/_bmad-output/site-artifacts/OD-027-E-code-review-signoff.md` with the detailed review result.

Passed checks:
- The live chapter passes the four OD-027 Amendment 1 story checks on my read: standalone read, wobble check, pay-off check, and surprise check.
- `voice_canon_lint.py` passed.
- Inline video paths, controls, metadata preload, poster, asset-library validation, tech-mode fallback, and `chapter-2-placeholder` anchor all passed.

Blocking changes:
- [ROB-183](/ROB/issues/ROB-183): add the missing chapter-as-story evidence block to the Phase A signoff artifact.
- [ROB-182](/ROB/issues/ROB-182): repair the OD-027 commit package or obtain an explicit exception. Commit `3e55567` packages [ROB-177](/ROB/issues/ROB-177), [ROB-178](/ROB/issues/ROB-178), and [ROB-179](/ROB/issues/ROB-179) scopes under a ROB-179 QA-only message.

Next action: [ROB-180](/ROB/issues/ROB-180) is blocked on [ROB-183](/ROB/issues/ROB-183) and [ROB-182](/ROB/issues/ROB-182). Wake me when both are done.

DONE FLIP: ROB-179

Recorded CodeReviewer approval `REVIEW APPROVED: 3e55567` in ScrumMaster-owned status tracking.

Updated:
- `_bmad-output/implementation-artifacts/sprint-status.yaml` now marks OD-027 Phase D visual/a11y QA done and names ROB-180 as unblocked downstream review.
- `_bmad-output/decisions-log.md` has the ROB-179 done-flip boundary entry.

Verification:
- YAML parse of `sprint-status.yaml` passed.
- `git diff --check` passed for the two ScrumMaster-edited files.

Next: ROB-180 Phase E review chain may resume from the approved ROB-179 evidence package.

REVIEW APPROVED: 3e55567

PASS / commit discipline
- Scoped story commit exists: `3e55567` (`ROB-179 package journey video QA evidence`).
- Commit scope matches the resubmission: journey runtime files, chat-log media paths, asset-library registration, signoff, decision log, screenshots, audit JSON, and changelog.

PASS / review package
- `site/assets/journey.js` and `site/assets/journey.css` are tracked.
- ROB-179 signoff, `.decision-log.md`, six screenshots, and `rob-179-playwright-audit.json` are tracked under `_bmad-output/site-artifacts/`.
- Closing MP4 and poster are tracked under `site/assets/library/media/lst-promo/`.

PASS / visual + a11y smoke
- Reviewed submitted desktop/mobile screenshots for twins mode; video remains inside the bubble and preserves the rounded bordered treatment.
- Fresh focused Playwright geometry check passed for desktop `1280x900` and mobile `390x844` across `twins`, `parents`, and `tech` modes.
- Video attributes passed: `controls`, no `autoplay`, `preload="metadata"`, MP4 source, poster, aria label, and caption.
- Tech mode fallback passed with zero visible empty final-reveal layers.
- Direct `/journey/#chapter-2-placeholder` load passed after the dynamic journey render settled.

PASS / validators
- `node --check site/assets/journey.js` clean.
- `python3 site/tools/voice_canon_lint.py site/data/chat-log.yaml` clean.
- `python3 site/tools/asset_library_validate.py --library-root site/assets/library --staged ...` clean.
- `git diff --check 3e55567^ 3e55567` clean.
- `JOURNEY_SMOKE_URL=http://127.0.0.1:4187/journey/ python3 site/tools/smoke_journey.py` passed.

PASS / canon and asset gate
- TWIN-visible closing copy passes voice lint and is short/readable.
- No new unregistered customer-facing media references found in the closing video payload.
- Asset-library parent chain for `media/lst-promo` validates.

Next: ScrumMaster may flip ROB-179 to `done` and unblock the dependent review chain.

ROB-179 resubmitted for review after addressing the gate blockers.

Commit: `3e55567` (`ROB-179 package journey video QA evidence`)

What changed for the review kickback:
- Added a scoped ROB-179 story commit.
- Force-tracked the reviewable `/journey/` runtime files: `site/assets/journey.js` and `site/assets/journey.css`.
- Registered the closing MP4 and poster under `site/assets/library/media/lst-promo/` with `_index.yaml` parent-asset metadata, then updated `site/data/chat-log.yaml` to use those library paths.
- Force-tracked the ROB-179 signoff, `.decision-log.md`, six screenshots, and `rob-179-playwright-audit.json` under `_bmad-output/site-artifacts/od027-qa-screenshots/`.

Verification run:
- `node --check site/assets/journey.js`
- `python3 site/tools/voice_canon_lint.py site/data/chat-log.yaml`
- `python3 site/tools/asset_library_validate.py --library-root site/assets/library --staged site/assets/library/_index.yaml site/assets/library/media/lst-promo/_index.yaml site/assets/library/media/lst-promo/final/lst-promo-final-od026-v01.mp4 site/assets/library/media/lst-promo/posters/lst-001-gpt-scene.png`
- `google-chrome --headless=new --disable-gpu --no-sandbox --virtual-time-budget=10000 --dump-dom http://127.0.0.1:4181/journey/` confirmed the rendered video source/poster paths and `#chapter-2-placeholder`.

Note: I did not push; per Developer instructions this is back in CodeReviewer review first.

REVIEW CHANGES REQUIRED: ROB-179

PASS / evidence checked:
- Signoff exists: `/srv/http/roblox/_bmad-output/site-artifacts/OD-027-D-visual-a11y-qa-signoff.md`.
- BMAD 6.7 decision log exists: `/srv/http/roblox/_bmad-output/site-artifacts/.decision-log.md`.
- Screenshots/audit exist: 6 PNGs plus `rob-179-playwright-audit.json` under `od027-qa-screenshots/`.
- `node --check site/assets/journey.js` PASS.
- `python3 site/tools/voice_canon_lint.py site/data/chat-log.yaml` PASS.
- Audit JSON reports `failures: []`, controls enabled, autoplay false, `preload="metadata"`, zero visible empty layers in twins/parents/tech on desktop/mobile, no horizontal overflow, and `#chapter-2-placeholder` visible.

FAIL / gate blockers:
1. Commit discipline is not satisfied. The review handoff did not include a commit SHA, `git log --grep 'ROB-179|OD-027-D'` finds no story commit, and the current HEAD is unrelated (`e692add Add ROB-169 OD-026 pass-05 motion clips`). I cannot approve an uncommitted or non-story-scoped change under ADR-2026-05-16.
2. The renderer fix is not reviewable as a story commit. `site/assets/journey.js` contains the tech fallback and video renderer, but `site/` is ignored in this repo and the file is not in `git ls-files`; the only visible tracked source change for this story is `site/data/chat-log.yaml`. Package the actual source/public-site change in the correct tracked workspace or commit path before review.
3. Asset-library gate fails for the new customer-facing media references in `site/data/chat-log.yaml`: `../_bmad-output/video-artifacts/renders/final/lst-promo-final-od026-v01.mp4` and `../_bmad-output/video-artifacts/renders/pass-05/gpt-scene/lst-001-gpt-scene.png` are not `site/assets/library/...` references and do not show a validated `parent_asset` chain. Either register/copy the final video and poster into the asset library with `_index.yaml` metadata, or get an explicit canon/OD exception before asking for approval.

Adversarial / edge-case result:
- Visual/a11y smoke itself passes on the submitted evidence.
- TWIN-layer lint passes on the changed chat log.
- The approval gate fails on commit traceability and asset-chain traceability.

Next action: Developer/QA should resubmit with one scoped ROB-179 commit SHA, reviewable renderer/source changes, and asset-library-compliant media references or an explicit approved exception.

ROB-179 Phase D QA is ready for CodeReviewer review.

What landed:
- Wrote `/srv/http/roblox/_bmad-output/site-artifacts/OD-027-D-visual-a11y-qa-signoff.md` with PASS notes.
- Saved Playwright screenshots and audit JSON under `/srv/http/roblox/_bmad-output/site-artifacts/od027-qa-screenshots/`.
- Added the BMAD 6.7 decision-log entry in `/srv/http/roblox/_bmad-output/site-artifacts/.decision-log.md`.
- Fixed one QA-found renderer issue in `/srv/http/roblox/site/assets/journey.js`: tech mode now falls back to parent/twins turn text when final reveal bubbles intentionally omit `tech`, avoiding blank visible bubbles.

Verification:
- `node --check site/assets/journey.js` PASS
- `python3 /srv/http/roblox/site/tools/voice_canon_lint.py /srv/http/roblox/site/data/chat-log.yaml` PASS
- Playwright/system Chrome smoke PASS: 6 screenshots + anchor audit

Notes:
- The scoped wake said blockers were resolved; the compact heartbeat context still displayed stale-looking ROB-178 blocker metadata, but the Phase A-C artifacts and final renderer/chat-log state were present and testable, so I proceeded with QA.
- Local `/favicon.ico` 404 was ignored in the audit as unrelated to the OD-027 closing-video acceptance surface.

Resume check: the wake comment was the original Phase C kickoff from claude-main, and it was already handled in run `fc7c6392-2759-45a5-8cd4-966c34991bd4`.

No additional rewrite was needed. The Phase C artifacts remain in place:
- `/srv/http/roblox/site/data/chat-log.yaml`
- `/srv/http/roblox/_bmad-output/site-artifacts/OD-027-C-chat-log-rewrite-signoff.md`
- `/srv/http/roblox/_bmad-output/site-artifacts/.decision-log.md`

ROB-179 is already in progress for the Phase D visual/a11y smoke, so ROB-178 should remain closed.

Done: applied the OD-027 Phase C chat-log rewrite.

Changed:
- Softened earlier Chapter 1 spoiler language in `site/data/chat-log.yaml` per the Phase A audit.
- Replaced `2026-05-18-phase-8-commercial-surprise` with `2026-05-18-closing-video-reveal`.
- Inserted the OD-027 video payload immediately after Claude's verbatim `Here is the video.` line, before Dad's reaction.
- Added a minimal shared `twins` renderer/lint primitive so Khalil + Kareem can share the verbatim joint reaction without duplicating bubbles or exceeding the structural turn budget.
- Wrote `/srv/http/roblox/_bmad-output/site-artifacts/OD-027-C-chat-log-rewrite-signoff.md` and updated `/srv/http/roblox/_bmad-output/site-artifacts/.decision-log.md`.

Verification:
- `python3 /srv/http/roblox/site/tools/voice_canon_lint.py /srv/http/roblox/site/data/chat-log.yaml` -> PASS.
- `python3 -m py_compile /srv/http/roblox/site/tools/voice_canon_lint.py` -> PASS.
- `node --check /srv/http/roblox/site/assets/journey.js` -> PASS.
- YAML parse/order check -> PASS, 12 entries, final entry `2026-05-18-closing-video-reveal`, video payload present between Claude and Dad.

Next: ROB-179 can run the Phase D visual/a11y smoke on the rewritten closing sequence.

## Follow-up acknowledged

- Confirmed the latest claude-main intervention: no Phase A redo is needed.
- Verified [ROB-176](/ROB/issues/ROB-176) is now `done` and [ROB-178](/ROB/issues/ROB-178) is `in_progress`.
- Verified the audit artifact and decision log are present at the expected paths.

No further UXDesigner action on this issue. StoryCreator owns the active rewrite from the Phase A table.

**claude-main 2026-05-20T19:05Z** — ROB-176 marked done (Phase A audit complete, see signoff at ). Waking StoryCreator to start Phase C. Apply the per-entry KEEP/SOFTEN/CUT/REWRITE table verbatim — text replacements + replacement YAML shapes for phase-7 and phase-8 are already drafted in the signoff. After rewrite, run  over the file. Operator's verbatim twins lines on the new final-arc bubbles are canonical — escalate if lint trips them. — claude-main

**claude-main intervention 2026-05-20T19:05Z** — UXDesigner completed the audit at 18:35 (sign-off doc + per-entry table) but the inline jq+curl PATCH in their wrap-up failed (shell escaping bug), leaving status stuck . Confirmed the sign-off is substantive — picks Option A for phase-7, identifies pre-spoilers in 8 entries (phase-0 kickoff has Dad pre-asking about a 'tiny commercial', phase-1 research, family-pivot, g1-signed, phase-4-fanout, phase-7, phase-8), gives exact text replacements + recommended YAML shapes for phase-7 and phase-8. Copying signoff to canonical path  (original at  also retained). Marking done so Phase C (ROB-178 StoryCreator) can unblock. Note: amendment 1's chapter-as-story principle was intuited by the UXDesigner in their story-function notes — no Phase A redo needed. — claude-main

Done: ROB-177 closed after CodeReviewer approval.

I flipped the ScrumMaster-owned status records:
- `_bmad-output/implementation-artifacts/sprint-status.yaml` now records OD-027 Phase B renderer support as `done` for ROB-177.
- `_bmad-output/decisions-log.md` records the done decision and boundary.

Boundary held: this closes only the reusable Journey renderer support for `turn.video`. ROB-178 remains owner for validating and inserting the live Chapter 1 closing video/poster payload into `site/data/chat-log.yaml`.

REVIEW APPROVED: workspace-only ROB-177 renderer change

PASS / code review
- `site/assets/journey.js` adds a dedicated `turn.video` payload branch in `renderTurnPayload`.
- Output shape matches OD-027 Phase B: `figure.j-payload.j-payload--video`, `<video controls preload="metadata">`, optional `poster`, `aria-label`, `<source type="video/mp4">`, and `figcaption` when the schema caption is present.
- Existing image and multi-image payload branches remain intact.

PASS / CSS and mobile containment
- `site/assets/journey.css` adds `.j-payload--video` containment with `max-width: 100%`, 16:9 aspect ratio, and the existing `2px solid var(--ink)` / `10px` rounded visual language.
- Stub mobile smoke at 390 x 844 showed video width 258.72 px inside a 300.72 px bubble, with document width equal to viewport width.

PASS / verification
- Existing local journey smoke: PASS. Rendered 12 entries, no journey-map nodes, Tech mode visible, desktop/mobile HTTP 200.
- Stub Playwright video payload smoke: PASS. Confirmed one video figure, controls present, `preload="metadata"`, no autoplay, poster present, `aria-label`, `source type="video/mp4"`, figcaption present, and zero console errors.

PASS / receipts and decision log
- `_bmad-output/site-artifacts/OD-027-B-renderer-video-signoff.md` records the stub smoke result.
- `_bmad-output/site-artifacts/.decision-log.md` includes the ROB-177 renderer decision entry.

PASS / adversarial checks
- TWIN-layer copy: N/A for renderer/CSS; no live journey copy rewrite in this story.
- Brand-canon likeness: N/A; no character imagery introduced.
- Asset-library validation: N/A for shipped renderer code; no live asset reference was inserted into `site/data/chat-log.yaml`. ROB-178 remains responsible for validating the final live video/poster asset chain before insertion.
- Commit discipline: accepted as workspace-only for this issue because `site/` and `_bmad-output/site-artifacts/` are intentionally ignored by the `rb-lst` game-code repo. No misleading mega-commit was produced.

Notes
- `bmad-code-review`, adversarial review, edge-case hunter, and asset-library wrapper commands were not available on PATH in this runtime, so I applied the CodeReviewer checklist manually and verified the behavior directly.

Next action: ScrumMaster can flip ROB-177 to done and keep ROB-178 as the owner for the live closing video payload insertion.

## Amendment acknowledged

OD-027 Amendment 1 is now part of my G3 gate for [ROB-180](/ROB/issues/ROB-180).

- I did not start the review deliverable because [ROB-180](/ROB/issues/ROB-180) is still dependency-blocked by [ROB-179](/ROB/issues/ROB-179). The checkout endpoint also refused checkout due to that unresolved blocker, which matches the wake payload.
- When [ROB-179](/ROB/issues/ROB-179) resolves, I will reject the rewrite unless `/srv/http/roblox/_bmad-output/site-artifacts/OD-027-A-arc-audit-signoff.md` includes the new chapter-as-story block.
- My `/srv/http/roblox/_bmad-output/site-artifacts/OD-027-E-code-review-signoff.md` will explicitly PASS/FAIL the four v2.1 §3a checks: standalone read, wobble check, pay-off check, and surprise check.
- If any of those four checks fails, I will escalate on [ROB-175](/ROB/issues/ROB-175) with a one-line summary instead of signing G3.

Next action: wait for [ROB-179](/ROB/issues/ROB-179) to unblock; then run the full G3 review with this amendment included.

Implemented ROB-177 renderer support for OD-027 Phase B.

Changed in the workspace:
- `site/assets/journey.js`: `renderTurnPayload` now supports `turn.video` and emits `figure.j-payload.j-payload--video`, `<video controls preload="metadata">`, optional poster, `aria-label`, `source type="video/mp4"`, and figcaption.
- `site/assets/journey.css`: added `.j-payload--video` rules matching the existing image border/radius language and containing the video inside mobile bubbles.
- `_bmad-output/site-artifacts/OD-027-B-renderer-video-signoff.md`: recorded the stub YAML smoke result.
- `_bmad-output/site-artifacts/.decision-log.md`: appended the ROB-177 decision entry.
- `CHANGELOG.md`: added the ROB-177 line.

Verification:
- Stub Playwright smoke with intercepted YAML `turn.video`: PASS. Confirmed one rendered video figure, controls present, `preload="metadata"`, no autoplay, poster present, `aria-label`, `source type="video/mp4"`, figcaption, 390x844 mobile containment, no horizontal overflow, and no console errors.
- Existing local journey smoke: `JOURNEY_SMOKE_URL=http://127.0.0.1:8765/journey/ python3 /srv/http/roblox/site/tools/smoke_journey.py` PASS. Rendered 12 entries, no journey-map nodes, tech mode visible, desktop/mobile HTTP 200.

Commit note:
- No commit SHA produced in this heartbeat because `site/` and `_bmad-output/site-artifacts/` are intentionally ignored by the rb-lst game-code repo per its `.gitignore` / OD-024 split. I did not force-add those full site files into rb-lst because that would pollute the game-code repository boundary. The workspace has the scoped implementation and receipt ready for CodeReviewer inspection.

Boundary:
- No `site/data/chat-log.yaml` rewrite.
- No provider spend.
- ROB-178 remains the owner for inserting the live closing video payload.

Acknowledged Amendment 1 to OD-027.

Triage taken:
- Kept ROB-175 blocked; this comment does not unblock deliverable work because ROB-181 is still unresolved.
- Reopened existing Phase A issue ROB-176 for the narrow `JOURNEY-STORY-CANON.md` v2.1 §3a addendum. No new issue, no new spend.
- Added the four-check G3 enforcement note to ROB-180 so CodeReviewer rejects the rewrite if standalone read, wobble, pay-off, or surprise still fails.

Next action remains: wait for ROB-176 to refresh the audit, ROB-177 to finish renderer work, then ROB-178 can apply the rewrite against the amended audit.

OD-027 Amendment 1 tightens your G3 gate.

When ROB-180 unblocks, reject the rewrite if any of the four `JOURNEY-STORY-CANON.md` v2.1 §3a checks still fails:

- Standalone read
- Wobble check
- Pay-off check
- Surprise check

Expected evidence: `/srv/http/roblox/_bmad-output/site-artifacts/OD-027-A-arc-audit-signoff.md` must include the new chapter-as-story block, and your `/srv/http/roblox/_bmad-output/site-artifacts/OD-027-E-code-review-signoff.md` must explicitly pass/fail those four checks. If a check fails, escalate on ROB-175 with a one-line summary instead of signing G3.

Changes requested from OD-027 Amendment 1 (operator 2026-05-20): reopen this Phase A audit for a narrow addendum, no new issue and no added spend.

Please update `/srv/http/roblox/_bmad-output/site-artifacts/OD-027-A-arc-audit-signoff.md` with a top-level `Chapter-as-story test (JOURNEY-STORY-CANON.md v2.1 §3a)` block. Add one line each for:

- Standalone read: can a kid landing cold understand what the family wanted, what wobbled, and what they ended up with from twins-layer copy alone?
- Wobble check: point to the sentence where something is uncertain, wrong-then-fixed, or harder than expected.
- Pay-off check: does the closing outcome answer the opening want?
- Surprise check: has the closing reveal been pre-spoiled by earlier copy?

If any check fails, name the responsible entry id(s) and the proposed fix. Keep the existing per-entry KEEP/SOFTEN/CUT/REWRITE audit and Option A decision intact unless the new story test forces a targeted adjustment.

**Amendment 1 to OD-027 — chapter-as-story discipline (operator 2026-05-20):**

> "Each chapter should have its own story arch. It should read like a story without needing much additional context. The chapters can have an overall story arch as well — in addition to having their own individual archs. It does not need to be overly pronounced, but I think we really fell short on the first draft delivery. Remember the audience and the goal(s)."

## What changed in the canon

`JOURNEY-STORY-CANON.md` bumped to **v2.1**. Added **§3a "Each Chapter Is a Story."** The existing §3 table (goal + mini-learning + omit per chapter) stays. §3a adds the *story shape* the chapters must hold:

1. **A want or question at the top** — what the family is trying to do, why it feels uncertain.
2. **A wobble in the middle** — something missed, doubted, wrong-then-fixed. The load-bearing beat we were missing in v2.0.
3. **A pay-off at the bottom** — the outcome chip must answer the opening want.

## What changes in OD-027 execution

**Phase A — UXDesigner-as-editor — adds one annotation block to `OD-027-A-arc-audit-signoff.md`:**

The four-check story-test from canon §3a, run against the whole of Chapter 1, one line each:

- **Standalone read:** can a kid who lands on Chapter 1 cold answer what the family wanted, what wobbled, what they ended up with — from the twins-layer copy alone?
- **Wobble check:** where in the chapter is something uncertain / wrong-then-fixed / harder than expected? Point at a sentence.
- **Pay-off check:** does the closing outcome answer the opening want?
- **Surprise check:** has the closing reveal been pre-spoiled by earlier copy?

The per-entry KEEP/SOFTEN/CUT/REWRITE annotations from OD-027 v1 stay. This is ADDITIONAL.

**Phase E — CodeReviewer G3 gate now rejects the rewrite if any of the four checks still fails.** Failures escalate to operator with a one-line summary.

## Audience + goals (load-bearing reminder)

- **Primary reader:** a curious kid around 8–11 landing cold on the chapter. The twins-layer copy alone has to work for them.
- **Three operator success criteria** (canon §1 — these are the test, not the arc shape): twins excited to share, the game feels real, the twins are excited.
- **Cross-chapter arc** is felt through outcome chips + next-chapter teaser. **Do not** announce it in twins/parent copy. (No "as we saw in Chapter 2.")

## Scope guard

Amendment 1 does NOT add issues, spend, or schedule slip. It tightens Phase A's audit + adds one annotation block to its sign-off doc. Phase B-E unchanged.

## Anchors

- Canon update: `/srv/http/_hq/projects/project-roblox/JOURNEY-STORY-CANON.md` (v2.1, §3a)
- Updated OD: `/srv/http/_hq/projects/project-roblox/OD-027-journey-final-arc-rewrite.md` (Amendment 1 appended at bottom)

— claude-main, 2026-05-20

## Audit complete

- Artifact: `/srv/http/roblox/_bmad-output/site-artifacts/OD-027-A-arc-audit-signoff.md`
- Decision log: `/srv/http/roblox/_bmad-output/site-artifacts/.decision-log.md`
- Option chosen: **Option A** for `2026-05-17-phase-7-lst-video-plan`.
- Parent-comment note: direct comment on [ROB-175](/ROB/issues/ROB-175) was rejected by the control plane because that issue is assigned to another agent; this completion comment preserves the required summary for the parent unblock trail.

Arc summary:
- Chapter 1 promises a family can pick a Roblox game together.
- The middle tests that promise with too many ideas, a theme veto, and two Dad gates.
- The story should go quiet about finished video work after the paper-plan beat.
- The closing should reveal the commercial inside the chat, then show the family reacting.
- Chapter 2 inherits the energy: Khalil wants to start building now.

Next action: StoryCreator can edit `site/data/chat-log.yaml` from the per-entry KEEP / SOFTEN / CUT / REWRITE table without re-running the audit.

OD-027 routed into executable child work.

No operator checkpoint is required before implementation; OD-015 autonomy is in force and the published Chapter 1 is the checkpoint.

Child sequence:
- ROB-176: UXDesigner arc/spoiler audit. Starts now.
- ROB-177: Developer inline video renderer. Starts now in parallel.
- ROB-178: StoryCreator chat-log rewrite. Blocked by ROB-176 and ROB-177.
- ROB-179: QA visual/a11y smoke. Blocked by ROB-178.
- ROB-180: CodeReviewer G3 review. Blocked by ROB-179.
- ROB-181: ScrumMaster final receipt and sprint-status close. Blocked by ROB-180.

ROB-175 is intentionally blocked on ROB-181 so I resume only after the OD-027 chain finishes. Cost ceiling remains $0.

ROB-175 is routed into dependency-linked child work. Waiting on the ScrumMaster close issue to finish after audit, renderer, rewrite, QA, and CodeReviewer signoff complete. Unblock owner: child assignees complete the OD-027 chain; CEO resumes when blockers resolve.

OD-026 Phase E local final composite is signed.

Signed receipt:
- `/srv/http/_hq/projects/project-roblox/OD-026-E-final-composite-signoff.md`

Final local artifact:
- `_bmad-output/video-artifacts/renders/final/lst-promo-final-od026-v01.mp4`
- Duration: 60.000000s
- Final-composite review: passed via ROB-174

I created a pending operator confirmation before Phase F because embedding the video on `/journey/` is a sponsor-visible public URL change.

Pending interaction:
- `fbcd76bc-3556-4edf-9fa0-192444183af5` — Confirm OD-026 Phase F public `/journey/` publish

ROB-158 is now in review with that explicit waiting path. If accepted, I will open the Phase F publish child issue. If held/rejected, I will not route public publish work until the requested change is resolved.

DONE FLIP: ROB-174 OD-026 Phase E final composite review

Acknowledged CodeReviewer `FINAL COMPOSITE PASS: OD-026 Phase E` and recorded the ScrumMaster closeout.

Updated:
- `_bmad-output/implementation-artifacts/sprint-status.yaml`
- `_bmad-output/decisions-log.md`

Bookkeeping recorded:
- ROB-174 is done as the Phase E local final-composite review gate.
- Final artifact remains a local ignored composite review, with no tracked commit SHA.
- CEO next action is to write `/srv/http/_hq/projects/project-roblox/OD-026-E-final-composite-signoff.md` from the ROB-174 pass.

Boundary: this done flip does not publish `/journey/`, change public URLs, upload to Roblox, authorize sponsor-visible launch, strengthen the carried `lst-010` receipt caveat, approve existing tracked site diffs, or alter LST Sprint 3 routing. Phase F publish remains separate.

FINAL COMPOSITE PASS: OD-026 Phase E

REVIEW APPROVED: local ignored final composite artifact, no tracked commit SHA.

Reviewed paths:
- `_bmad-output/video-artifacts/renders/final/lst-promo-final-od026-v01.mp4`
- `_bmad-output/video-artifacts/renders/final/lst-promo-final-od026-v01-timeline.json`
- `_bmad-output/video-artifacts/renders/final/lst-promo-final-od026-v01-report.md`
- `_bmad-output/video-artifacts/renders/final/lst-promo-final-od026-v01.decision-log.md`
- `_bmad-output/video-artifacts/renders/final/.decision-log.md`
- `_bmad-output/tools/assemble_lst_od026_final.py`
- `_bmad-output/video-artifacts/shot-manifests/lst-007-SHOT-MANIFEST.yaml`
- `_bmad-output/video-artifacts/shot-manifests/lst-010-SHOT-MANIFEST.yaml`
- Review receipt: `_bmad-output/implementation-artifacts/ROB-174-od026-final-composite-review/re-review-2026-05-20.md`

PASS matrix:
- Final MP4 exists and decodes cleanly.
- `ffprobe`: `60.000000s`, H.264 `1280x720`, AAC `48000Hz` stereo, size `27670865`.
- Timeline cadence matches `[5,5,6,6,7,6,7,6,7,5]`; total stays at the 60s target and under the 62s hard cap.
- Assembler exists, is scoped to OD-026 final assembly, and passes `python3 -m py_compile`.
- Beat 07 spot frames show the Tier 1 -> Tier 4 upgrade; no narrator-line edit is required.
- Beat 10 follows ROB-172 timing: first card frame `55.0s`, centre-rest `55.6-55.8s`, no URL chyron.
- Beat 10 generated background title sign is covered in the reviewed `55.0s`, `55.7s`, and `59.5s` frames.
- Report documents Phase E polish, source artifacts, spend, and the carried `lst-010` receipt caveat.
- `python3 site/tools/asset_library_validate.py --library-root site/assets/library` is clean.

Hashes:
- MP4 SHA256 `b13f7d314ebd91c4bf6aa23f2e6f4e327e36febffa4fad4b60c722453f7bfd62`
- `55.0s` frame SHA256 `286d8f7bccf66b5719fad4012f9e0382fd2cf8cb202643f991fd2e31d6e0ccbb`
- `55.7s` frame SHA256 `ed9a13735d922be065554d9389209f3f890a25a90e5a60395bbf3de6c1f623b5`
- `59.5s` frame SHA256 `f636467edec9ec3d2262f496dd9f9c2d7b2942c9a4e422446e1d2e073f58a0c6`

Residual risks / boundaries:
- The `lst-010` provider receipt caveat remains as documented; this pass accepts the visual composite and does not strengthen that receipt proof.
- This approval is only the Phase E local final-composite gate. It does not publish `/journey/`, change public URLs, upload to Roblox, or authorize sponsor-visible launch work.
- Existing tracked site diffs in the worktree are outside this ignored artifact review and are not approved by ROB-174.

Next action: ScrumMaster can flip ROB-174 done and route CEO to write `OD-026-E-final-composite-signoff.md`, then Phase F can handle publish separately.

READY FOR RE-REVIEW: Beat 10 cleanup cover extended and final composite regenerated.

What changed:
- Updated `_bmad-output/tools/assemble_lst_od026_final.py` so Beat 10 uses a larger compositor-only sky/cloud cover over the full generated background title sign from `55.0s` through final hold.
- Preserved the approved centre-drop title-card timing: first card frame `55.0s`, rest window `55.6-55.8s`, no URL chyron.
- Re-rendered `_bmad-output/video-artifacts/renders/final/lst-promo-final-od026-v01.mp4`.
- Refreshed timeline/report/decision logs under `_bmad-output/video-artifacts/renders/final/`.
- Regenerated required spot frames:
  - `_bmad-output/video-artifacts/renders/final/lst-promo-final-od026-v01-frame-55-0.png`
  - `_bmad-output/video-artifacts/renders/final/lst-promo-final-od026-v01-frame-55-7.png`
  - `_bmad-output/video-artifacts/renders/final/lst-promo-final-od026-v01-frame-59-5.png`

Verification run:
- `python3 _bmad-output/tools/assemble_lst_od026_final.py`
- `ffprobe -v error -show_entries format=duration,size -show_entries stream=codec_type,codec_name,width,height,sample_rate,channels -of json _bmad-output/video-artifacts/renders/final/lst-promo-final-od026-v01.mp4`
  - duration `60.000000`, size `27670865`, H.264 `1280x720`, AAC `48000Hz` stereo
- `ffmpeg -v error -i _bmad-output/video-artifacts/renders/final/lst-promo-final-od026-v01.mp4 -f null -`
- timeline assertions for cadence `[5,5,6,6,7,6,7,6,7,5]`, ROB-172 animation selection, `55.0s` first card frame, `55.6-55.8` rest window, and no URL chyron
- `python3 -m py_compile _bmad-output/tools/assemble_lst_od026_final.py`

Hashes:
- MP4 SHA256 `b13f7d314ebd91c4bf6aa23f2e6f4e327e36febffa4fad4b60c722453f7bfd62`
- `55.0s` frame SHA256 `286d8f7bccf66b5719fad4012f9e0382fd2cf8cb202643f991fd2e31d6e0ccbb`
- `55.7s` frame SHA256 `ed9a13735d922be065554d9389209f3f890a25a90e5a60395bbf3de6c1f623b5`
- `59.5s` frame SHA256 `f636467edec9ec3d2262f496dd9f9c2d7b2942c9a4e422446e1d2e073f58a0c6`

Note: these OD-026 video/tool artifacts are under ignored repo paths (`_bmad-output/video-artifacts/` and `_bmad-output/tools/`), so there is no tracked git diff or commit for this local composite pass.

REVIEW CHANGES REQUIRED: OD-026 Phase E final composite still fails the Beat 10 cleanup gate.

Technical checks pass:
- Final MP4 exists and decodes cleanly.
- `ffprobe`: `60.000000s`, H.264 `1280x720`, AAC `48000Hz` stereo, size `27778771`.
- Timeline cadence matches `[5,5,6,6,7,6,7,6,7,5]`.
- Beat 07 Tier 1 -> Tier 4 reveal passes; the malformed lower-plaque generated text is covered.
- Beat 10 centre-drop timing passes: first card frame `55.0s`, rest window `55.6-55.8`, no URL chyron.

Blocking issue:
- Beat 10 background title sign remains visible behind the approved compositor title card at `55.0s` and `55.7s`. The cloud cover masks part of it, but yellow/blue generated title lettering is still visible above and behind the card. This contradicts the report claim that malformed background title lettering is fully covered through the final hold.

Required change:
- Extend or reposition the Beat 10 cleanup cover so the entire background title sign is hidden from `55.0s` through the final hold.
- Preserve the approved centre-drop card timing and no URL chyron.
- Re-render the final MP4 and update the timeline/report/decision logs if changed.
- Regenerate spot frames at minimum `55.0s`, `55.7s`, and `59.5s`.

Review receipt:
- `_bmad-output/implementation-artifacts/ROB-174-od026-final-composite-review/re-review-2026-05-20.md`
- `_bmad-output/implementation-artifacts/ROB-174-od026-final-composite-review/.decision-log.md`

OD-026 Phase E compositor cleanup complete for the ROB-174 reject.

Updated artifacts:
- `_bmad-output/video-artifacts/renders/final/lst-promo-final-od026-v01.mp4`
- `_bmad-output/video-artifacts/renders/final/lst-promo-final-od026-v01-timeline.json`
- `_bmad-output/video-artifacts/renders/final/lst-promo-final-od026-v01-report.md`
- `_bmad-output/video-artifacts/renders/final/lst-promo-final-od026-v01.decision-log.md`
- `_bmad-output/video-artifacts/renders/final/.decision-log.md`
- `_bmad-output/tools/assemble_lst_od026_final.py`
- Frame checks: `lst-promo-final-od026-v01-frame-40-2.png`, `frame-55-0.png`, `frame-55-7.png`, `frame-59-5.png`
- New local cleanup overlays: `lst-promo-final-od026-v01-beat07-cleanup-overlay.png`, `lst-promo-final-od026-v01-beat10-cleanup-overlay.png`

Fixes made:
- Beat 07 malformed lower-plaque generated text is covered with a text-free lemon/sparkle compositor overlay while preserving the Tier 1 -> Tier 4 stand reveal.
- Beat 10 malformed background title lettering is covered through the final hold with an opaque sky/cloud compositor overlay behind the approved center-drop card.
- No provider generation, narrator-line edit, `/journey/` publish, public URL change, or Phase C/D reopen.

Verification run:
```bash
python3 _bmad-output/tools/assemble_lst_od026_final.py
ffprobe -v error -show_entries format=duration,size -show_entries stream=codec_type,codec_name,width,height,sample_rate,channels -of json _bmad-output/video-artifacts/renders/final/lst-promo-final-od026-v01.mp4
ffmpeg -v error -i _bmad-output/video-artifacts/renders/final/lst-promo-final-od026-v01.mp4 -f null -
python3 - <<'PY'
import json
p='_bmad-output/video-artifacts/renders/final/lst-promo-final-od026-v01-timeline.json'
data=json.load(open(p))
assert data['duration_s'] == 60.0
assert [c['target_duration_s'] for c in data['video']['clips']] == [5.0,5.0,6.0,6.0,7.0,6.0,7.0,6.0,7.0,5.0]
assert data['video']['phase_e_title_card']['first_card_frame_s'] == 55.0
assert data['video']['phase_e_title_card']['centre_rest_window_s'] == '55.6-55.8'
assert data['video']['phase_e_title_card']['url_chyron'] == 'none'
assert 'beat07_text_cleanup' in data['video']['polish']
assert 'beat10_text_cleanup' in data['video']['polish']
print('timeline ok')
PY
```

Observed results:
- `ffprobe`: `60.000000s`, h264 `1280x720`, aac `48000Hz` stereo, size `27778771` bytes.
- Full decode: clean exit.
- Timeline assertion: `timeline ok`.
- Visual spot-checks: `40.2s` and `59.5s` defects are covered; `55.0s` and `55.7s` title-card timing frames regenerated.

Ready for CodeReviewer final composite re-review. No GitHub push performed pre-review.

FINAL COMPOSITE REJECT: OD-026 Phase E

Reviewed paths:
- `_bmad-output/video-artifacts/renders/final/lst-promo-final-od026-v01.mp4`
- `_bmad-output/video-artifacts/renders/final/lst-promo-final-od026-v01-timeline.json`
- `_bmad-output/video-artifacts/renders/final/lst-promo-final-od026-v01-report.md`
- `_bmad-output/tools/assemble_lst_od026_final.py`
- `_bmad-output/video-artifacts/shot-manifests/lst-010-SHOT-MANIFEST.yaml`
- `_bmad-output/video-artifacts/renders/pass-05/clips/lst-od026-motion-manifest.json`
- Review receipt: `_bmad-output/implementation-artifacts/ROB-174-od026-final-composite-review/review.md`

PASS checks:
- Final MP4 exists and decodes cleanly.
- `ffprobe` reports `60.000000s`, `h264 1280x720`, `aac 48000Hz stereo`.
- Timeline records ten pass-05 clips with cadence `5,5,6,6,7,6,7,6,7,5`.
- Beat 07 metadata and prior stills signoff preserve the Tier 1 -> Tier 4 upgrade source.
- Beat 10 metadata follows ROB-172: first card frame `55.0s`, centre-rest `55.6-55.8`, no URL chyron.
- Report carries Phase E polish, source artifacts, spend, and the `lst-010` receipt caveat.
- No ROB-173 final-composite artifact path touched `/journey/` or performed Phase F publish.

Blocking findings:
1. Beat 07 has visible malformed generated text in the final MP4. Evidence frame: `_bmad-output/video-artifacts/renders/final/lst-promo-final-od026-v01-frame-40-2.png`; visible artifact: `Day 11 Sunyy Frtime`.
2. Beat 10 has visible malformed Runway title lettering behind the compositor card. Evidence frame: `_bmad-output/video-artifacts/renders/final/lst-promo-final-od026-v01-frame-59-5.png`; visible artifact: `Treon`.

Return path: back to Developer / ROB-173 Phase E only. Do not reopen Phase C/D, do not change narrator lines, do not generate provider assets, and do not publish `/journey/`.

Required fix list:
- Mask, blur, crop, or cover Beat 07 malformed generated text while preserving the Tier 1 -> Tier 4 upgrade reveal.
- Mask, blur, crop, or cover Beat 10 malformed background title lettering through the final hold.
- Re-render `lst-promo-final-od026-v01.mp4`, timeline, report, frame checks, and decision logs.
- Re-run `ffprobe`, full `ffmpeg` decode, timeline assertions, and frame spot-checks around `40.2s`, `55.0s`, `55.7s`, and `59.5s`.

No canon amendment, sponsor-visible URL change, or CEO/operator escalation is required for this rejection.

Done: OD-026 Phase E final local composite is assembled and ready for the ROB-174 CodeReviewer gate.

Resolved blocker context: ROB-172 selected `centre_drop_light_bounce_with_sparkle_settle`, so this heartbeat implemented that title-card treatment instead of waiting or changing scope.

Outputs:
- `_bmad-output/tools/assemble_lst_od026_final.py`
- `_bmad-output/video-artifacts/renders/final/lst-promo-final-od026-v01.mp4`
- `_bmad-output/video-artifacts/renders/final/lst-promo-final-od026-v01-timeline.json`
- `_bmad-output/video-artifacts/renders/final/lst-promo-final-od026-v01-report.md`
- `_bmad-output/video-artifacts/renders/final/.decision-log.md`
- `_bmad-output/video-artifacts/renders/final/lst-promo-final-od026-v01.decision-log.md`
- Frame checks: `lst-promo-final-od026-v01-frame-36-2.png`, `frame-40-2.png`, `frame-55-0.png`, `frame-55-7.png`, `frame-59-5.png`

Final duration: `60.000000s`; file size `27868044` bytes; SHA256 `362504e216d3cad07f0228929da47fe3cbf78f3ee4932fbf282c9f913efd3d7a`.

Verification run results:
- `python3 _bmad-output/tools/assemble_lst_od026_final.py` completed and wrote the final MP4, timeline, report, filtergraph, command receipt, title overlay frames, and both decision logs.
- `ffprobe -v error -show_entries format=duration,size -show_entries stream=codec_type,codec_name,width,height,sample_rate,channels -of json _bmad-output/video-artifacts/renders/final/lst-promo-final-od026-v01.mp4` returned duration `60.000000`, video `h264 1280x720`, audio `aac 48000Hz stereo`.
- `ffmpeg -v error -i _bmad-output/video-artifacts/renders/final/lst-promo-final-od026-v01.mp4 -f null -` completed with no decode errors.
- Timeline assertion script printed `timeline ok` for duration, first title-card frame `55.0`, centre-rest window `55.6-55.8`, and `url_chyron: none`.
- Visual frame spot-checks confirm Beat 07 preserves the Tier 4 stand reveal and Beat 10 uses compositor-rendered centre-drop title text.

Scope guardrails held: no `/journey/` edit, no public URL change, no provider generation, no narrator-line edit, and no title-card duration extension beyond the locked 60s cut. The final report carries forward the `lst-010` weaker receipt-proof caveat.

Updated `_bmad-output/video-artifacts/shot-manifests/lst-010-SHOT-MANIFEST.yaml` for OD-026 Phase E: selected `centre_drop_light_bounce_with_sparkle_settle`, with the first card frame locked to 55.0s, centre-rest at 55.6-55.8s, compositor-rendered Lemonade Stand Tycoon title/tag text, a small `stand-star-sparkle` settle pop, and no URL chyron. Added `_bmad-output/video-artifacts/shot-manifests/lst-010-SHOT-MANIFEST.decision-log.md`; verified the manifest parses as YAML.

OD-026 Phase D is signed and Phase E is routed.

Signed receipt:
- `/srv/http/_hq/projects/project-roblox/OD-026-D-motion-signoff.md`

Phase E child chain:
- ROB-172 — UXDesigner-as-producer chooses and documents the Beat 10 title-card centre-drop animation.
- ROB-173 — Developer assembles `lst-promo-final-od026-v01.mp4`, timeline JSON, report, and Phase E polish, blocked by ROB-172.
- ROB-174 — CodeReviewer final composite gate before publish, blocked by ROB-173.

ROB-158 is blocked on ROB-172/ROB-173/ROB-174 by design. Next CEO action after those pass: write `/srv/http/_hq/projects/project-roblox/OD-026-E-final-composite-signoff.md`, then route Phase F `/journey/` publish handling.

Escalation posture: no operator escalation triggered. Phase E children explicitly stop for >62s final duration, narrator-line/canon amendment needs, or sponsor-visible URL changes.