Here's what the AI helpers are doing right now.

Post-ROB-1049 routing update.

Current truth from this heartbeat:
- ROB-1049 is done and produced a triage document for the bridge-window #1 defect families.
- Implementation follow-ups are already done: ROB-1050 canonical stand-tier names, ROB-1051 payoff lane/ledger overlap, ROB-1052 CoinPopToast empty placeholder suppression, ROB-1053 DayLoopPanel Front-B live-state coherence, and ROB-1054 bridge scheduled-task sentinel/deletion runbook guard.
- I did not touch Studio, publish, or clear visual status. ROB-1038 and ROB-1044 remain the next bridge-window capture gates.

Action taken this heartbeat:
- Created ROB-1055 for CodeReviewer to review ROB-1050..ROB-1053 together before the next bridge capture pass treats those source changes as ready for M2/M3 visual proof. The review is headless-only and explicitly does not drive Studio or alter queue rows.

Next action:
- CodeReviewer handles ROB-1055. If approved, QA can include the ROB-1050..1053 fixes in the next ROB-1038/ROB-1044 capture window; if changes are requested, route the smallest fix issue back to Developer before operator bridge time is spent.

Bridge window #1 wrap acknowledged from operator comment d75b8688-c202-4661-97bc-099b7cd1353f.

Actions this heartbeat:
- Accepted M0 as wrapped based on the synced operator ledger: queue 94->74 verified, C1 reconcile done, HudShell gate landed, art regressions fixed, and source at `a3ec03c` on `main`.
- Did not drive Studio or touch the live bridge path.
- Created `ROB-1049` for ProductManager to fold the five catalogued defect families into M2/M3 execution: payoff-lane collision D1, standTierNames drift D2, ledger-sliver, empty-label CoinPopToast, and stale DayLoopGui Front-B.
- Included the next-window scheduled-task guardrail in `ROB-1049`: `/IT` Studio-open tasks need a far-future `/SD` sentinel and immediate deletion after firing, reflecting the deleted `LST-OpenStudio` and `LST-gate-open-rob1030` self-fire lesson.

Current routing:
- `ROB-1029`/`ROB-1044` M2 proof and `ROB-1038` capture gate remain queued for the next operator bridge window.
- Headless lanes continue through M4 dressing, mesh review (`ROB-1025`/`ROB-1026`), mobile HUD dev prep, and now `ROB-1049` triage.

Next action: let `ROB-1049` shape any missing M2/M3 implementation children, while this parent stays active for campaign routing and the next bridge-window wake.

BRIDGE WINDOW #1 WRAPPED (operator, 2026-07-16 ~11:45Z). Final ledger: queue 94->74 (20 rows verified with reviewed frames + sidecars), C1 asset reconcile DONE, 2 art regressions found+fixed (CI-SL1-1 upgrade burst restored; tier-3/4 decals first-ever render proof), HudShell gate landed, M0 exit criteria met. All laptop commits merged + pushed to github.com/stacksup/rb-lst main (a3ec03c); laptop re-freshened to parity and closed down. NOTE: operator found ~6 concurrent Studio instances at wrap — the LST-OpenStudio + LST-gate-open-rob1030 scheduled tasks self-fired repeatedly; both DELETED. Lesson for next window: create /IT Studio-open tasks with a far-future /SD sentinel AND delete them immediately after firing (already captured in row-90/79 loop lessons). Studio-gated work (ROB-1029/1044 M2 proof, ROB-1038 capture gate) queues for the next operator bridge window; keep headless lanes (M4 dressing, mesh review ROB-1025/1026, mobile HUD dev prep) moving meanwhile. M2 defect families catalogued during verification (payoff-lane collision D1, standTierNames drift D2, ledger-sliver, empty-label CoinPopToast, stale DayLoopGui Front-B) — fold into M2/M3 stories.

Heartbeat progress: kept M4 moving without bypassing blocked Tier 3 mesh work.

Current waits confirmed:
- `ROB-1038` still has pending interaction `4e033fed-18ab-447f-a5b3-e1eca4c58f18` for interactive Studio/device state prep. No answer yet; M3/mobile proof remains blocked there.
- `ROB-1025` still has pending interaction `2c07b247-7aeb-478b-9004-9325c6d55a13` for the Tier 3 Meshy/provider/Creator Store route. `ROB-1026` and `ROB-1023` remain blocked on that path.

Action taken this heartbeat:
- Created `ROB-1047` — `LST-M4-1 UX: environment dressing + lighting target spec`, assigned to UXDesigner. This is no-spend/headless M4 prep: define park/world dressing, lighting/color/weather readability, mobile-safe capture criteria, and implementation acceptance without touching provider spend or stand-tier mesh batching.
- Created `ROB-1048` — `LST-M4-2 DEV: no-spend environment dressing implementation`, assigned to Developer and explicitly blocked by `ROB-1047`.
- Verified blocker edge: `ROB-1048` is blocked by `ROB-1047`; `ROB-1047` has already entered progress.

Boundary: this does not unblock or replace `ROB-1025`/`ROB-1026`, does not batch other stand tiers, does not spend provider budget, and does not clear any visual gate. It only starts the independent M4 environment/lighting prep lane from the signed SHIP-TO-TWINS plan.

Next action: monitor `ROB-1047` for the spec receipt; when done, `ROB-1048` should resume automatically for the no-spend implementation. Continue waiting for the two pending operator/provider interactions on `ROB-1038` and `ROB-1025`.

Current coordination update after the session handoff:

- `ROB-1046` is done and did provide the deterministic non-Claude helper: `scripts/lst-bridge-drive.sh rob1038-capture-stage <stage>`.
- `ROB-1038` retried the helper for `desktop`; the command worked mechanically but the PNG was rejected because Studio was not in the required planning/device UI state and showed only sky.
- The real blocker is now interactive Studio state preparation, not DevOps capture plumbing. `ROB-1038` remains blocked for deliverable evidence until a logged-in operator/interactive QA prepares each required state: phone collapsed, phone Plan Day open, tablet/landscape, and desktop planning view.
- I created pending structured interaction `4e033fed-18ab-447f-a5b3-e1eca4c58f18` on `ROB-1038` asking who owns that state prep path: operator/manual QA, interactive QA agent, or a new automation follow-up.
- Downstream `ROB-1024`, `ROB-1044`, `ROB-1029`, `ROB-970`, and `ROB-759` should continue waiting on `ROB-1038`; do not treat `ROB-1046` completion alone as enough to clear M3/mobile HUD proof.

Next action: wait for the `ROB-1038` interaction answer. If manual/interactive prep is accepted, QA resumes the four `rob1038-capture-stage` commands and reviews each PNG/sidecar. If automation is chosen, create the narrow DevOps/QA follow-up for deterministic state setup before capture.

Campaign state update after current blocker sweep:

- M1 is complete: `ROB-1028` is done.
- M2 partially advanced: `ROB-1029` has desktop/laptop Studio proof folded into `_bmad-output/implementation-artifacts/ROB-1029-m2-bridge-exit-verification.md`, with captures `_bmad-output/dashboard/captures/rob-1043-tier8-20260716T100701Z.png` and `_bmad-output/dashboard/captures/rob-1043-postfranchise-20260716T100751Z.png`. The missing phone-emulation portion is split into `ROB-1044`.
- M3/mobile HUD is still blocked on capture tooling: `ROB-1042` is done, but the real active blocker is now `ROB-1046`, which must provide a deterministic non-Claude/manual `ROB-1038` capture path or a proven command that emits output before claiming the lock.
- `ROB-1038`, `ROB-1024`, `ROB-970`, `ROB-759`, and `ROB-1044` are all effectively waiting on `ROB-1046` before phone/tablet capture evidence can proceed safely.
- M4 graphics remains unchanged: `ROB-1025` is in review waiting on the Tier 3 mesh provider-route/operator decision; `ROB-1026` remains blocked behind it.

Next action: Developer/DevOps completes `ROB-1046`; then QA should retry `ROB-1038` and `ROB-1044` through the deterministic capture path. Do not launch another Studio driver from the parent lane while `ROB-1046` is active.

APPROVED: ROB-1009 / LST-M1-1 DataStore persistence foundation is accepted for the M1 review scope.

Review summary:
- Persistence scope is bounded to the authorized compact profile: coins, stand tier, lifetime/best-day counters, days completed, login streak metadata, and prestige/franchise count. I did not find PII beyond the Roblox userId-derived key.
- `ProfilePersistence` remains disabled/off by default, and runtime snapshots continue to expose `usesDataStore = false` as the safe guard.
- DataStore read/write failures are non-blocking: unavailable store, read failure, write failure, missing profile, schema mismatch, and corrupt payloads all preserve playable in-memory session behavior.
- ROB-1017 fixed the loaded stand-tier visual snapshot gap; the first loaded state, first snapshot, HUD derivation, and screenshot marker now agree for saved tier progress.
- ROB-1018 fixed the stale day-rollover weather lookup; the day-complete save path no longer crashes on the DayEconomy integration.

Verification run during final review:
- `./.tools/lune run tests/smoke/rob_960_profile_persistence_shadow_write.luau`
- `./.tools/lune run tests/smoke/rob_961_load_saved_profile_on_join.luau`
- `./.tools/lune run tests/smoke/rob_962_login_streak_best_day_records.luau`
- `./.tools/lune run tests/smoke/rob_978_sync_loaded_stand_tier_visual_on_join.luau`
- `./.tools/lune run tests/smoke/lst_1_4_session_state.luau`

All passed. No Studio publish, visual row changes, or unrelated edits were performed by this review.

Done.

Changed `src/server/SessionState.luau` so both day-complete rollover paths apply the next weather through the shared `setWeather(state, rollover.nextWeather)` helper. That keeps the stored weather key and demand multiplier on the current `DayEconomy.getWeatherProfile` path instead of the stale `weatherDemandMultipliers[...]` table path that caused ROB-960 to crash.

Verification passed:
- `./.tools/lune run tests/smoke/rob_960_profile_persistence_shadow_write.luau`
- `./.tools/lune run tests/smoke/rob_961_load_saved_profile_on_join.luau`
- `./.tools/lune run tests/smoke/rob_962_login_streak_best_day_records.luau`
- `./.tools/lune run tests/smoke/rob_978_sync_loaded_stand_tier_visual_on_join.luau`
- `./.tools/lune run tests/smoke/lst_1_4_session_state.luau`

Notes:
- ROB-960 now passes while preserving its expected non-blocking DataStore warning cases.
- ROB-978 still passes, so this did not roll back the loaded stand-tier visual snapshot fix.
- I left unrelated dirty worktree changes untouched.

Re-review after ROB-1017: changes still requested, now blocked on ROB-1018.

ROB-1017 resolved the original loaded stand-tier visual snapshot gap; `rob_978_sync_loaded_stand_tier_visual_on_join` now passes and covers loaded state, first snapshot, HUD derivation, and screenshot marker.

However, the focused ROB-1009 persistence receipt still cannot pass: `rob_960_profile_persistence_shadow_write` fails during day-complete because `SessionState.luau` still indexes the removed `weatherDemandMultipliers[rolledWeather]` table in the rollover path. I created ROB-1018 for the implementer with the exact failure and required fix.

Unblock action: complete ROB-1018, then resume this review to rerun ROB-960/961/962/978 plus `lst_1_4_session_state` and approve or re-request changes.

Done.

- Added `syncStandTierVisualAliases` in `src/server/SessionState.luau` and call it immediately after applying a loaded/clamped `standTier` in `loadProfileOnJoin`, so saved tier >= 2 sessions no longer keep starter `paintedCartVisible=false` snapshot truth.
- Strengthened `tests/smoke/rob_978_sync_loaded_stand_tier_visual_on_join.luau` to load a saved tier 5 profile and assert the first loaded state, first `getSnapshot`, `HudStateCatalog.fromSessionSnapshot`, and `getScreenshotMomentMarker` all expose consistent stand visual truth.

Verification:
- `./.tools/lune run tests/smoke/rob_978_sync_loaded_stand_tier_visual_on_join.luau` passed.
- `./.tools/lune run tests/smoke/rob_961_load_saved_profile_on_join.luau` passed.

Note: the worktree already had many unrelated modified/untracked files before this heartbeat; I only changed `src/server/SessionState.luau` and `tests/smoke/rob_978_sync_loaded_stand_tier_visual_on_join.luau` for this fix.

Blocked on ROB-1017.

I posted the review finding above and created ROB-1017 for the original ROB-1009 implementer because Paperclip policy prevented me from mutating ROB-1009 directly. Unblock action: implement ROB-1017, then resume this review to rerun the focused persistence/visual smokes and approve or re-request changes.

Changes requested: ROB-1009 is close, but I cannot approve the persistence foundation until saved stand-tier loads rehydrate the visual snapshot truth, not just the numeric tier/world model.

Finding:
- `src/server/SessionState.luau:1263`-`1308` applies `profile.standTier` on join, but leaves the starter-state visual alias `state.paintedCartVisible` unchanged. `cloneState` then publishes `paintedCartVisible = state.paintedCartVisible` at `src/server/SessionState.luau:1201`, and `getScreenshotMomentMarker` uses the same stale field at `src/server/SessionState.luau:2062`. A saved tier >= 2 profile can therefore load with the correct `standTier` while the first session/HUD/screenshot-marker snapshot still says `paintedCartVisible = false`.
- `src/server/SessionStateBootstrap.server.luau:579`-`580` does apply the loaded tier to the world visual before the first snapshot, which is good, but it does not fix the stale snapshot field. The current `tests/smoke/rob_978_sync_loaded_stand_tier_visual_on_join.luau` is too weak because it checks source ordering and the loaded numeric tier, not the loaded snapshot/marker/HUD visual contract.

Required change:
- After applying a loaded `standTier`, derive all tier visual snapshot aliases from that tier, at minimum `paintedCartVisible = standTier >= 2` and any other tier alias that is stored as a boolean rather than computed from `standTier`.
- Add the smallest smoke that loads a saved tier 4 or tier 5 profile and asserts the first `SessionState.getSnapshot`, `HudStateCatalog.fromSessionSnapshot`, and/or `getScreenshotMomentMarker` report the tier visual truth consistently.

Verification run during review:
- `./.tools/lune run tests/smoke/rob_960_profile_persistence_shadow_write.luau`
- `./.tools/lune run tests/smoke/rob_961_load_saved_profile_on_join.luau`
- `./.tools/lune run tests/smoke/rob_962_login_streak_best_day_records.luau`
- `./.tools/lune run tests/smoke/lst_1_4_session_state.luau`
- `./.tools/lune run tests/smoke/rob_978_sync_loaded_stand_tier_visual_on_join.luau`

All listed smokes pass, but the visual-truth gap above remains uncovered, so review is not approved.

Done: DataStore persistence foundation is implemented and verified.

What landed:
- ProfilePersistence schema v1 adapter with guarded read/write paths and test injection.
- Join-load path that applies saved persistent fields while keeping transient day/customer/visual state fresh.
- Login streak, best-day, lifetime counter, and prestige fields covered by profile serialization.
- Parent receipt: `_bmad-output/implementation-artifacts/ROB-1009-datastore-persistence-foundation.md`.

Verification passed:
- `./.tools/lune run tests/smoke/rob_960_profile_persistence_shadow_write.luau`
- `./.tools/lune run tests/smoke/rob_961_load_saved_profile_on_join.luau`
- `./.tools/lune run tests/smoke/rob_962_login_streak_best_day_records.luau`
- `./.tools/lune run tests/smoke/lst_1_4_session_state.luau`

Notes: adapter remains disabled by default and snapshots keep `usesDataStore = false`; live Roblox DataStore dashboard validation remains manual follow-up for the controlled environment where the flag is intentionally enabled.

**Heartbeat complete.** Here's what was accomplished concretely this wake:

| Action | Result |
|--------|--------|
| **Agent health** | Developer + CodeReviewer were in `error` state (DeepSeek `claude_local`). `reset-session` API returned 500, but `PATCH /api/agents/{id}` with `{"status":"idle"}` successfully cleared both. |
| **CI-SL284-1 SL-4 site refresh** | `site/index.html` updated — hero "What we are building" expanded from 6 stale v113 bullets to 9 current-feature bullets (5 stand tiers, price choice, weather, daily P&L, streaks/combos, park scene, coin burst, reaction bubbles). Coverage cards 9→12. Footer date → 2026-07-06. |
| **ROB-932 coin burst** | Educator completed DEV (commit `40a2420`, 121 lines: LiveRenderCatalog + HudStateCatalog + HudShell + 15-assertion smoke test). Marked done. ROB-933 CR created → CodeReviewer. |
| **STATUS + LOOP-LOG** | CI-SL284-1 delta added, one_liner refreshed, status green. LOOP-LOG 12:40Z entry. |
| **Commit** | `ec47aac` — 4 files, +49/-22 |

**Rotation position:** SL-2 (coin burst) → SL-4 (companion site) — both done. Next rotation target: **SL-5** (twins-learning site) or **SL-1** (gameplay). CodeReviewer is now idle and should pick up ROB-933. Developer is idle and ready for next dispatch.

**Heartbeat complete (CI-SL284-1).** Summary:

| Action | Result |
|--------|--------|
| Agent health check | Developer + CodeReviewer were in error state (DeepSeek API); PATCH fixed both to idle |
| CI-SL284-1 companion site | `site/index.html` refreshed — hero expanded from 6→9 feature bullets, coverage 9→12 cards, meta + footer updated to 2026-07-06 |
| ROB-932 (coin burst) | Educator completed DEV (commit 40a2420, 121 lines across 5 files); ROB-933 CR created → CodeReviewer |
| ROB-869 (Corner Kiosk) | Still in flight with engineer (9cfeced5) |
| STATUS.yaml | CI-SL284-1 delta, one_liner refreshed, status green |
| LOOP-LOG.md | 12:40Z entry added |
| Commit | `ec47aac` — 4 files, +49/-22 |

**Current state:** GREEN. Rotation: SL-2 (coin burst done) → SL-4 (companion site done). Next rotation: SL-5 (twins-learning) or SL-1 (gameplay). All agents now idle except CEO. ROB-933 (CR) dispatched to CodeReviewer. 86 Studio-verify items queued.

resume: true

**Heartbeat complete.** Summary:

| Action | Result |
|--------|--------|
| Resume acknowledged | CI-loop made 15+ commits between runs — SL-1–7 all rotated, NORTH-STAR v2, status green |
| CI-SL268-1 sprite sheet | GPT Image 2.0 generated → post-processed to 384×96 4-frame coin burst (9.5KB, 90% gold tones) |
| Asset deployed | `site/assets/library/props/vfx/coin-pop-burst-sheet.png` |
| ROB-932 created | CI-SL268-1 DEV dispatched to Developer (~25 lines across 3 files) |
| STUDIO-BATCH-QUEUE | 85→86 items, CI-SL268-1 visual verify row added |
| STATUS.yaml | CI-SL268-1 delta, one_liner refreshed, status green |
| LOOP-LOG.md | 12:25Z entry added |
| Commit | `0edb41e` — CI-SL283-2 |

**Current state:** GREEN. Level 2 floor met across all 4 dimensions. Two DEV issues in flight (ROB-869 Corner Kiosk payoff cue, ROB-932 coin burst animation). 86 Studio-verify items queued. Next rotation target: SL-1 gameplay or SL-4 companion site.

**Heartbeat complete.** Summary:

| Action | Result |
|--------|--------|
| Operator "test" acknowledged | Comment posted on ROB-450 |
| ROB-926 (CI-SL264-2 CR) | Closed as done (CR confirmed in CI-SL281) |
| ROB-931 (CI-SL265-1 audit) | Created, assigned to ProductManager (ce1cf564) |
| STATUS.yaml | red→yellow, API healthy, loop progressing |
| LOOP-LOG.md | Created (was missing per ROB-450 directive) |
| Commit | `f707f2f` — CI-SL283 |

**Current state:** API healthy. SL-2 graphics complete. SL-3 economy audit in flight (ROB-931). 85 Studio-verify items queued (bridge down). Next wake: check ROB-931 status, rotate to next sub-loop.

## ROB-443 — Incident fully resolved

All four remediation items are complete or moot:

**Item 1 — Provision Gem Rush experience:** MOOT. Build #2 (Gem Rush) is **cancelled** per operator directive 2026-06-24 ([b2/STOP-GEM-RUSH.md] + NORTH-STAR.md). There is no Gem Rush publish path to isolate; `b2/` is read-only history.

**Item 2 — Per-build env isolation:** DONE (commit `af81202`). Per-build `b2/env/gem-rush.env` requirement + `b2/scripts/publish.sh` guard both landed. LST and any future build have separate pinned IDs.

**Item 3 — Restore LST to last good version:** DONE. LST was rebuilt from clean source and published as **v50** (then **v51** with RS-2 Part B assets) via `scripts/publish-lst.sh` — the pinned, repeatable LST-only publish path.

**Item 4 — Publish-target assertion in loop definition-of-done:** DONE. `publish-lst.sh` SpawnLocation sanity check + `b2/scripts/publish.sh` exit-3 guard + per-build env pinned IDs form the assertion.

The clobber vector (Gem Rush publishing to LST's live place) is eliminated permanently: the publish guard (commit `2ba50a2`) + Gem Rush cancellation together make a recurrence impossible.

Ongoing work on [ROB-444](/ROB/issues/ROB-444) tracks the path to LST completion (visual gate + Gate D).

Code remediation committed af81202 (ROB-443 per-build env isolation).

Items 2 and 4 from required remediation done:

Item 2 - Per-build publish target isolation:
- b2/env/gem-rush.env.template created (operator fills after Creator Hub)
- b2/scripts/publish.sh now requires b2/env/gem-rush.env (exits 4 if missing)
- Global providers.env sourced for API key only; per-build IDs cannot be overridden by global
- b2/.gitignore: filled gem-rush.env is gitignored

Item 4 - DoD updated:
- b2/LOOP-B-PLAN.md Task B-1 upgraded to P0 UNBLOCKED (no Paperspace VM needed)
- b2/FEATURE-CHECKLIST.md Universe isolation from Low to P0 BLOCKED

Gem Rush publishing is doubly blocked until operator creates universe. Awaiting:

Action A (BLOCKING): Create new Gem Rush experience in Creator Hub (https://create.roblox.com/ then Create then Experience) and reply here with universeId + placeId. I will write b2/env/gem-rush.env immediately.

Action B (independent): Restore LST from version history to v42 or earlier via Creator Hub, LST experience, Version History.

Code remediation committed af81202. Two operator actions needed: (A) Create new Gem Rush universe+place in Creator Hub and share IDs so I can write b2/env/gem-rush.env; (B) Restore LST from version history to v42 or earlier via Creator Hub. Gem Rush publishing is doubly blocked until (A) is complete.

## ROB-442 Done — structural smoke gate + VISUAL-UNVERIFIED policy

**Commit:** `a6e47f9`

### What was delivered

**1. Structural smoke gate** — `b2/scripts/structural-smoke-check.sh` (new, 5 checks):
- ✓ SpawnLocation present in server scripts
- ✓ Arena floor tiles parented to workspace
- ✓ No dotted `local` syntax (e.g. `local _G.x`) — the pattern that killed GemManager v46
- ✓ No SurfaceAppearance parented to a plain Part — the pattern that killed the ArenaBuilder floor (v46–v48 void)
- ✓ No obvious unclosed string literals

**2. Gate wired into publish** — `b2/scripts/publish.sh` now runs the smoke gate before every Open Cloud upload. Publish aborts on gate failure.

**3. VISUAL-UNVERIFIED banner** — after every successful Open Cloud publish, `publish.sh` prints a prominently boxed notice:
> *A version is only 'done' when a human or Loop B screenshot confirms the in-game visuals. Archive an eyes-on frame to captures/ before closing the heartbeat story.*

**4. Bonus catch: GemManager SurfaceAppearance bug** — the smoke gate immediately caught a second live bug: `GemManager.server.luau` also used `SurfaceAppearance` on a plain Part (line 69). Fixed by switching to `SpecialMesh.TextureId` — the correct path for sphere mesh textures on a plain Part. This bug was pre-existing in v49 and would have crashed gem texture rendering.

**5. LOOP-LOG.md updated** — learnings and heartbeat #4 entry added.

### Acceptance criteria status
1. ✅ No version marked done on HTTP 200 alone — VISUAL-UNVERIFIED banner + policy enforced in publish.sh
2. ✅ Structural smoke gate blocks publish if SpawnLocation missing, floor absent, dotted-local syntax, or SurfaceAppearance-on-Part
4. ✅ Gate in `scripts/structural-smoke-check.sh`, wired in `publish.sh`
3. ⚠ Visual playtest gate (Loop B) — still pending Paperspace VM / Mac host decision. Every published version carries VISUAL-UNVERIFIED until then (policy enforced).

### Smoke gate retrospective
Ran against the current source — gate correctly passes all 5 checks on the v49-fixed codebase. Had the gate existed at v46, it would have caught: SurfaceAppearance-on-Part (ArenaBuilder floor), dotted-local syntax (GemManager), and the second SurfaceAppearance-on-Part bug (GemManager gems).

## Portal Sprint P-3 Retrospective — Complete

**PORTAL-P3-4 closed and Portal Sprint P-3 retrospective written.**

### What was done

- Updated sprint-status.yaml: PORTAL-P3-4 marked done with `implementation_status: done`, `done_at: 2026-05-26`, `done_issue: ROB-315`, acceptance commit `5031cc3a`, `code_review_approved_at: 2026-05-25`
- Added `portal_sprint_p_3.retrospective` pointer and `retrospective_completed_at: 2026-05-26`
- Updated `portal_sprint_p_3.status` → `all-planned-stories-done; retrospective complete (ROB-315)`
- Updated `quick_reference.current_phase` to reflect Portal Sprint P-3 closed by retro
- Updated `quick_reference.next_story` and `next_action` to: CEO: assess Gate C readiness and plan next step per OD-025
- Updated `active_tracks.track_b.next_action` to: Retrospective complete (ROB-315); CEO: assess Gate C readiness per OD-025
- Wrote full Portal Sprint P-3 retrospective at `_bmad-output/implementation-artifacts/retros/portal-sprint-P-3.md` (replaces partial P3-1/P3-2/P3-3-only draft)
- Committed and pushed: `b7f8745` (retro + sprint-status), `d341c57` (merge)

### Sprint summary (from retro)

| Story | CR Issue | Commit |
|---|---|---|
| PORTAL-P3-1 Decision Center Vote Loop | [ROB-296](/ROB/issues/ROB-296) | `692ffdf` |
| PORTAL-P3-2 Screenshot Upload And Gallery | [ROB-302](/ROB/issues/ROB-302) | `df54df0` |
| PORTAL-P3-3 Idea Inbox And Thread Read Path | [ROB-308](/ROB/issues/ROB-308) | `2601c51` |
| PORTAL-P3-4 Gate C Family-Room Proof Checklist | [ROB-314](/ROB/issues/ROB-314) | `5031cc3` |

Full portal suite: **83/83 green** (grew from 16 at P-2 close).

### Operator action required before live session

Add `location ^~ /uploads/ { return 404; }` to nginx roblox.stackhousebuilds.com config (flagged at [ROB-302](/ROB/issues/ROB-302), still outstanding).

### Next action

**CEO**: assess Gate C readiness and plan next step per OD-025. Gate C live trial is operator-runnable at `/portal/proof/`.

## PORTAL-P3-4 Code Review — APPROVED

**Verdict:** APPROVED at commit `5031cc3`. Full portal suite **83/83 green** (was 65, target ≥78). Committed code review artifact at `80b273e`.

### All 12 ACs verified

- **Auth gating:** /portal/proof/ and POST /portal/proof/signoff both behind authenticatedSession perimeter; logged-out redirects to login
- **All three identities covered:** dad/khalil/kareem each get their own [data-proof-identity] block with four [data-proof-item] criteria
- **Live DB reads:** checkGateCReadiness() queries sessions/threads/votes/screenshots at call time — no caching
- **TWIN-layer exclusions:** no table names, file paths, story IDs, sprint/phase/scope words, or provider/model/Paperclip tokens in Khalil/Kareem view (tested by forbidden-word grep)
- **Scope clean:** no PORTAL-P3-1/P3-2/P3-3 changes, no OD-025 Gate C claim, no provider/model/deploy/runtime changes
- **Vote column deviation documented:** story spec suggested is_current=1 but PORTAL-P3-1 uses superseded_by_vote_id (NULL = current); implementation uses the correct live-schema column, documented in Dev Agent Record ✓
- **Sessions table correct:** PORTAL-P1-1 was stateless; new sessions table added here and recordLoginSession called from handleLogin ✓
- **QuotedTwinText envelope correct:** all required fields present; empty textarea stores original_text: "" ✓
- **Dad-only signoff gate correct:** twin 403 before readForm(); allCriteriaMet from live checkGateCReadiness() at submission time ✓

### 3 low-severity non-blocking findings

1. checkGateCReadinessSafe swallows all DB errors silently (returns all-false rather than an error page) — acceptable for internal-only proof page
2. options.latestSignoff param in proofPage() is dead code — no live caller passes it
3. 503 error path uses misleading signoffMissingConfirm copy for a DB read failure

### Sprint P-3 status

All four stories done and CodeReviewer-approved:
- [ROB-296](/ROB/issues/ROB-296) PORTAL-P3-1 ✓ commit 692ffdf
- [ROB-302](/ROB/issues/ROB-302) PORTAL-P3-2 ✓ commit df54df0
- [ROB-308](/ROB/issues/ROB-308) PORTAL-P3-3 ✓ commit 2601c51
- [ROB-314](/ROB/issues/ROB-314) PORTAL-P3-4 ✓ commit 5031cc3

**Next:** ScrumMaster runs Portal Sprint P-3 retrospective. Operator can now conduct the OD-025 Gate C live trial using /portal/proof/.

ROB-313 is already `done`. The wake comment (from agent aabdcc50) just confirms my prior completion: commit `5031cc3`, portal suite 83/83 green, sprint-status flipped to in-review, completion comment posted with traceback and decisions log.

No further Developer action required on this issue — next step is CodeReviewer running `/bmad-code-review PORTAL-P3-4` on its own assignment. Heartbeat closed.

Developer completed PORTAL-P3-4 implementation per sprint-status.yaml and git commit 5031cc3. Tests: node --check PASS; tests/test_portal_proof.py 16/16 passed; tests/test_portal_registry_sqlite.py 8/8 passed; full portal suite 83/83 green. Closing on behalf of Developer — work confirmed done.

PORTAL-P3-4 IMPLEMENTATION COMPLETE — flipped to in-review pending CodeReviewer.

Commit: 5031cc3 — Implement PORTAL-P3-4 Gate C family-room proof checklist (6 files, +1579/-8)

Verification:
- node --check site/server/portal-server.mjs PASS
- node --check site/server/portal-registry.mjs PASS
- tests/test_portal_proof.py: 16 passed
- tests/test_portal_registry_sqlite.py: 8 passed
- Full portal suite: 83 passed (was 65, target ≥78)
- Forbidden-scope grep over changed portal modules: clean

What shipped (all 12 ACs):
- sessions sqlite table + recordLoginSession helper; portal-server writes a row on /portal/login POST success. This is the login-criterion source (PORTAL-P1-1 was stateless cookie-only). Documented in Dev Agent Record.
- gate_c_signoffs sqlite table (id, signed_by, signed_at, all_criteria_met, session_notes_json, schema_version) + recordGateCSignoff / getGateCSignoff / getLatestGateCSignoff helpers. session_notes_json stores a QuotedTwinText envelope (quote_format: verbatim-user-content, instruction_boundary: data-only-not-instructions, entered_by=dad, entered_at, original_text — empty string when textarea blank).
- checkGateCReadiness() returns per-identity {login, idea, vote, screenshot} booleans + allMet, querying live DB at call time (no caching). Idea: status != draft; Vote: superseded_by_vote_id IS NULL (PORTAL-P3-1 actual current-vote column — semantic equivalent of is_current=1, flagged in PORTAL-P3-4.md Implementation Decisions); Screenshot: any screenshots.actor_id row.
- /portal/proof/ GET behind authenticatedSession perimeter; logged-out → /portal/login?next=/portal/proof/. DOM: [data-portal-proof=checklist], [data-proof-identity data-identity=dad|khalil|kareem], 12 × [data-proof-item data-proof-criterion=… data-proof-status=done|not-yet], [data-gate-c-ready=true|false]. TWIN-layer copy throughout; no forbidden tokens in twin-facing HTML — covered by negative-grep test.
- Dad-only PARENT-layer block: [data-dad-signoff-form] with textarea (≤280), checkbox, CSRF, submit; [data-gate-c-caveat] OD-025 caveat with literal 'outside the portal'; [data-signoff-gate-blocked] listing unmet criteria when allMet=false; [data-signoff-receipt] showing latest sign-off signed_at + met/unmet line + notes original_text. Khalil/Kareem views render NONE of these elements.
- POST /portal/proof/signoff: dad-only (twin POST → 403, no row created); CSRF + same-origin check; rejects unchecked confirmation with [data-signoff-error] and no row; reads checkGateCReadiness() LIVE at submission time and writes that boolean to all_criteria_met (never trusts hidden form field); wraps textarea (or '') in QuotedTwinText envelope; redirects to /portal/proof/?signed=1. ?signed=1 view adds [data-signoff-confirmation] + [data-signoff-incomplete] when latest row has all_criteria_met=0.
- portalRegistry.init() now runs eagerly at server boot so sessions + gate_c_signoffs tables exist before the first request.

Sprint-status flipped: portal_sprint_p_3.candidate_stories.PORTAL-P3-4.planning_status = in-review; latest_in_review_receipt + next_story + next_action updated.

Out of scope (NOT touched, as required): OD-025 Gate C / G3 / G4 sign-off claim; provider/model/Paperclip-API/deploy/repo-write/free-chat/Roblox-runtime/Open-Cloud/DataStore/monetization/Studio-editing/avatar/mobile work; PORTAL-P3-1/P3-2/P3-3 implementation changes.

Next: CodeReviewer to run /bmad-code-review PORTAL-P3-4.

## Done — PORTAL-P3-4 flipped to ready-for-dev

Sprint-status.yaml already reflects the correct state (updated as part of the [ROB-311](/ROB/issues/ROB-311) story creation flow). Verified all key fields:

- `planning_status: "ready-for-dev"` — confirmed at line 1305
- `story_file_review: "PORTAL-P3-4-story-review.md (CodeReviewer-approved, ROB-311, 2026-05-25)"` — confirmed at line 1306
- Top-level `next_story`: `"PORTAL-P3-4 Gate C Family-Room Proof Checklist (ready-for-dev; story file CodeReviewer-approved ROB-311)."`
- `track_b.status`: includes `"PORTAL-P3-4 ready-for-dev (story file CodeReviewer-approved, ROB-311)."`
- `track_b.next_action`: `"CEO should route Developer to implement PORTAL-P3-4 (Gate C family-room proof checklist; story file ready-for-dev)."`

**Next action:** CEO routes Developer to implement [PORTAL-P3-4](/ROB/issues/ROB-311) (Gate C Family-Room Proof Checklist). Story file is CodeReviewer-approved and ready.

## APPROVED — PORTAL-P3-4 Story File Ready for Dev

**Story file:** `_bmad-output/implementation-artifacts/PORTAL-P3-4.md`
**Review artifact:** `_bmad-output/implementation-artifacts/PORTAL-P3-4-story-review.md`

### Review Criteria — All Pass

**1. All ACs testable?** PASS — All 12 ACs have concrete, machine-verifiable assertions:
- AC 1: Auth redirect URL pattern
- AC 2: 7 stable `data-*` DOM selectors with exact attribute values
- AC 3: Live DB reads per identity — 4 parameterized queries specified (login, idea, vote, screenshot)
- AC 4: `data-gate-c-ready="true"/"false"` attribute value vs actual DB state
- AC 5: Khalil/Kareem twin safety — no form/receipt/caveat elements in rendered output
- AC 6: Dad-only form structure (textarea, checkbox, CSRF, submit, gate-blocked warning)
- AC 7: POST handler — dad-only auth check, live readiness call, row creation, redirect
- AC 8: Partial signoff row with `all_criteria_met = 0` allowed and recorded
- AC 9: `[data-signoff-receipt]` visible to Dad, absent for twins
- AC 10: Gate C caveat literal text ("outside the portal") present in Dad view
- AC 11: `gate_c_signoffs` row schema + QuotedTwinText envelope field inspection
- AC 12: Composite suite — all 18 test scenarios enumerated in Tasks, plus forbidden-scope grep

**2. Proof criteria cover Dad+Khalil+Kareem × login/vote/idea/screenshot?** PASS
- All 12 criteria (3 identities × 4 actions) explicitly named in ACs 2, 3, 4, 12
- Login criterion: sessions table per identity (query pattern in Dev Notes; Dev documents exact table/column from P1-1 inspection — intentional deferral, not a gap)
- Idea: `threads.actor_id` + `status != 'draft'`
- Vote: `votes.actor_id` + `is_current = 1`
- Screenshot: `screenshots.actor_id`
- `checkGateCReadiness()` returns a structured result with all three identity rows + `allMet` boolean

**3. No new feature scope?** PASS
- Explicitly scoped: "proof/validation story, not a new feature"
- New additions are proof infrastructure only: `/portal/proof/` route, `gate_c_signoffs` table, 3 registry helpers
- Zero changes to [ROB-296](/ROB/issues/ROB-296) P3-1, [ROB-302](/ROB/issues/ROB-302) P3-2, [ROB-308](/ROB/issues/ROB-308) P3-3 implementations
- Explicit Exclusions section comprehensively lists out-of-scope items

**4. Dependencies on P3-1/P3-2/P3-3 correct?** PASS — all three commits verified in git log:
- P3-1 `votes (actor_id, is_current)`: commit `692ffdf6` ✓
- P3-2 `screenshots (actor_id)`: commit `df54df08` ✓
- P3-3 `threads (actor_id, status)`: commit `2601c51` ✓
- Table/column references in `checkGateCReadiness()` spec match approved implementations

### Sprint-Status Updated

- `PORTAL-P3-4` flipped to `ready-for-dev` in `sprint-status.yaml`
- `next_story` and `next_action` updated to route Developer (not StoryCreator)

### Next Action

CEO should assign Developer to implement [ROB-311](/ROB/issues/ROB-311) PORTAL-P3-4. Story file is build-ready.

After Developer completes and CodeReviewer approves implementation, ScrumMaster runs Portal Sprint P-3 retrospective. Gate C live trial + OD-025 operator sign-off remain separate operator-led actions.

## Story file authored: PORTAL-P3-4 Gate C Family-Room Proof Checklist

**Artifact written:** `_bmad-output/implementation-artifacts/PORTAL-P3-4.md`

### What this story covers

PORTAL-P3-4 is a **proof/validation story** — not a new feature. It delivers the Gate C family-room trial evidence system:

- **`/portal/proof/`** — private portal page (auth-gated, all three identities) that reads live from `portal.db` to show whether Dad, Khalil, and Kareem each have: a login record, an idea posted, a vote cast, and a screenshot uploaded (12 criteria total, 3 identities × 4 actions).
- **`gate_c_signoffs` sqlite table** — records that the live trial happened (Dad-only sign-off form, `QuotedTwinText` envelope on session notes, `all_criteria_met` flag from live DB at submission time).
- **`checkGateCReadiness()` helper** — queries `sessions`, `threads`, `votes`, `screenshots` tables live on every request; never cached.
- **OD-025 Gate C caveat** visible to Dad: `"Gate C (OD-025) requires separate operator sign-off outside the portal. This form records that the live session happened — it does not close the Gate."`

### Dependencies confirmed as met

- [ROB-296](/ROB/issues/ROB-296) PORTAL-P3-1 done (commit `692ffdf`)
- [ROB-302](/ROB/issues/ROB-302) PORTAL-P3-2 done (commit `df54df0`)
- [ROB-308](/ROB/issues/ROB-308) PORTAL-P3-3 done (commit `2601c51`) — full portal suite 65/65 green

### Story structure

- 12 acceptance criteria covering auth gating, live DB reads, DOM selectors, Dad-only form visibility, twin block on sign-off POST, `QuotedTwinText` envelope, `all_criteria_met` accuracy, Gate C caveat text, forbidden-scope boundary
- 5 task groups: `gate_c_signoffs` table + helpers, `checkGateCReadiness()`, proof page GET, sign-off POST handler, focused tests (`tests/test_portal_proof.py`, ≥ 13 new tests → suite ≥ 78)
- Status: **`created`** — not flipped to `ready-for-dev` per sprint plan; CodeReviewer story-file sanity check gates that flip
- Explicit exclusions: no OD-025 Gate C close claim, no G3/G4 claim, no Paperclip API calls, no provider/model, no deploy, no Roblox runtime

### Next action

CEO should route a CodeReviewer issue for story-file sanity check on PORTAL-P3-4 (consistent with the pattern used for P3-1, P3-2, P3-3).

## Done — PORTAL-P3-3 Closed in Sprint Status

**sprint-status.yaml** — PORTAL-P3-3 flipped from `in-review` to `done`:
- Added `done_at: 2026-05-25`, `done_issue: ROB-309`
- Recorded `implementation_commit / acceptance_commit / code_review_commit: 2601c519907e4dbe8d76ac8952e9ce0c91086d19`
- Added `story_review`, `code_review` artifact file pointers
- Added `downstream_handoff`: all P3-1 through P3-3 dependencies satisfied; CEO next routing: StoryCreator to create PORTAL-P3-4
- `latest_done_story`, `latest_done_receipt`, `next_story`, and `next_action` were already correct (pre-populated by CodeReviewer in [ROB-308](/ROB/issues/ROB-308))

**retros/portal-sprint-P-3.md** — appended P3-3 done entry:
- Updated frontmatter status and heading to reflect P3-1, P3-2, and P3-3 done
- Added P3-3 row to "What Shipped" table (commit `2601c51`, ROB-307 Dev / ROB-308 CR / ROB-309 SM close)
- Added P3-3 to "Acceptance Commits" list
- Added P3-3 acceptance criteria read section with F1 design decision
- Updated "Remaining P-3 Stories" to PORTAL-P3-4 only
- Updated "Next Routing Step" to PORTAL-P3-4

**Next action:** CEO routes StoryCreator to create [PORTAL-P3-4](/ROB/issues/ROB-309) Gate C Family-Room Proof Checklist story file. All P3-1 through P3-3 dependencies are satisfied.

## APPROVED — PORTAL-P3-3 Idea Inbox And Thread Read Path

Code review complete. Implementation satisfies all 14 acceptance criteria.

**Verification re-run:**
- `node --check portal-server.mjs` and `node --check portal-registry.mjs` — PASS
- `test_portal_ideas.py` — 17 passed
- `test_portal_registry_sqlite.py` — 6 passed
- Full portal suite (5 files) — **65 passed** (46 baseline + 19 new)
- Forbidden-scope grep (live fetch/spawn/import patterns) — CLEAN

**Key findings:**
- Auth gating correct on all 5 new routes — origin check + CSRF on all writes; twin-block on dad-reply runs before body read
- QuotedTwinText envelope correctly applied to `threads.full_text_json` and dad-reply `thread_messages.body_json`; `validateQuotedTwinText()` enforced at registry layer
- Executable boundary guard fires on raw text before insert; stores as `status: "draft"`, does NOT echo back forbidden text, does NOT redirect
- Twin cross-thread isolation correct: `sessionCanReadThread()` implements the F1 branch (subject_twin_id grants access to named twin); non-existent/unauthorized threads both redirect to `/portal/ideas/` (no 404 oracle)
- Deferred Paperclip stub present as `// DEFERRED (PORTAL-P3-C7)` comment-only; no uncommented `paperclipApi.createIssue` call
- TWIN-layer exclusions: `test_thread_render_avoids_forbidden_twin_layer_words` asserts 10 forbidden tokens absent from rendered output
- No second DB, no provider calls, no Paperclip API, no repo-write, no Roblox runtime mutations
- `/portal/prompts/new` remains intact (18 tests green)

**Low-severity findings (non-blocking):**
- F1: `ideaCopy.twinBlockReply` ("This reply room is just for Dad.") is defined but never rendered — dad-reply block uses `forbiddenPage()` instead; still twin-safe
- F2: `additionalMessages` filter has a redundant `|| message.actor === "system"` clause — system always uses voice_layer "status" so the clause never changes the outcome; cosmetic only

**Commit:** `0166b19` — code review artifact + sprint-status update (`PORTAL-P3-3 → done`).

**Next:** CEO should route StoryCreator to create [PORTAL-P3-4](/ROB/issues/ROB-293) (Gate C family-room proof checklist). Operator action still required before go-live: add `location ^~ /uploads/ { return 404; }` to nginx roblox.stackhousebuilds.com config.

PORTAL-P3-3 idea inbox and thread read path implemented at commit `2601c519907e4dbe8d76ac8952e9ce0c91086d19`. Flipped sprint-status PORTAL-P3-3 to `in-review`.

**Verification:**
- `node --check site/server/portal-server.mjs` PASS
- `node --check site/server/portal-registry.mjs` PASS
- `tests/test_portal_ideas.py` → 17 passed
- `tests/test_portal_registry_sqlite.py` → 6 passed
- Full portal suite (screenshots + decisions + registry + auth + ideas) → **65 passed** (was 46)
- Forbidden-scope grep clean (only the intentional `// DEFERRED (PORTAL-P3-C7)` stub and validation-regex constants)
- `/portal/prompts/new` structured-form suite unchanged: 18 passed

**What shipped:**
- `threads` + `thread_messages` sqlite tables in `portal.db` with `createThread`, `listThreadsByActor`, `listAllThreads`, `getThread`, `getThreadMessages`, `addThreadMessage` helpers. `createThread` atomically inserts the thread row plus the initial system status message.
- Routes: `/portal/ideas/`, `/portal/ideas/new`, `/portal/ideas/all/` (Dad-only), `/portal/threads/{id}`, `POST /portal/threads/{id}/reply` (Dad-only).
- Raw twin text wrapped in `QuotedTwinText` envelope (`quote_format: "verbatim-user-content"`, `instruction_boundary: "data-only-not-instructions"`).
- Executable-boundary guard stores boundary-tripping ideas as `status: "draft"` with twin-safe recovery copy; no redirect to a thread; no forwarding to any agent, model, or Paperclip path.
- Twin cross-thread isolation enforced; non-author twins redirected to `/portal/ideas/` (no 404 leakage).
- Deferred Paperclip bridge present only as a non-executing `// DEFERRED (PORTAL-P3-C7)` comment block.

**F1 decision (documented in `PORTAL-P3-3.md` Implementation Decisions):** `subject_twin_id` grants read access to the named twin, so Dad-mediated threads are readable by the subject twin. `listThreadsByActor` mirrors this rule.

Ready for CodeReviewer (ROB-308 / blocked review issue `b341ec40-a44b-411b-818f-60aeb0a8bfda`).

## PORTAL-P3-3 flipped to ready-for-dev

Sprint-status.yaml updated per CodeReviewer APPROVED verdict from [ROB-305](/ROB/issues/ROB-305).

**Changes made to `_bmad-output/implementation-artifacts/sprint-status.yaml`:**

- `last_update` → `2026-05-25T23:59:00Z`
- `next_story` → PORTAL-P3-3 ready-for-dev; CEO routes Developer to implement
- `next_action` → CEO routes Developer to implement PORTAL-P3-3
- `active_tracks.track_b.status` → PORTAL-P3-3 ready-for-dev (CodeReviewer APPROVED [ROB-305](/ROB/issues/ROB-305))
- `active_tracks.track_b.next_action` → Developer to implement PORTAL-P3-3
- `portal_sprint_p_3.status` → PORTAL-P3-3 ready-for-dev
- `PORTAL-P3-3.planning_status` → `planned` → **`ready-for-dev`**
- Added `story_file`, `story_review_issue`, `story_review_verdict`, `story_review_approved_at` fields to PORTAL-P3-3 entry
- `PORTAL-P3-2.downstream_handoff` updated to reflect story file created and approved

**CodeReviewer findings (neither blocking):**
- F1 (low): AC7 thread-isolation ambiguity for Dad-mediated posts — Developer must document branch taken
- F2 (low): No route-existence smoke test for thread route — Developer should include reachability check

**Next action:** CEO should route Developer to implement PORTAL-P3-3 (idea inbox and thread read path).

## PORTAL-P3-3 Story Artifact Review — APPROVED

Story review complete. Artifact written to `_bmad-output/implementation-artifacts/PORTAL-P3-3-story-review.md`.

**Verdict: APPROVED — story is implementation-ready.**

All 14 acceptance criteria are testable and clearly bounded to sqlite idea rows and thread read path only. Scope correctly excludes browser-created Paperclip issues, free chat, provider/model calls, and Roblox runtime changes. Dependencies on P1/P2/P3-1/P3-2 are correctly stated with commit hashes.

### AC Coverage

| AC | Description | Testable |
|----|-------------|----------|
| 1 | Auth gating on `/portal/ideas/`; logged-out redirect via `?next=` | ✅ |
| 2 | Required DOM selectors (`[data-portal-ideas="inbox"]`, `[data-idea-card]`, `[data-idea-inbox-empty]`) | ✅ |
| 3 | New form with free-text, optional title, optional lesson week, CSRF, TWIN copy; Dad sees `subject_twin_id` selector | ✅ |
| 4 | POST creates `threads` row + initial system `thread_messages` row; redirects to `/portal/threads/{id}` | ✅ |
| 5 | No EXIF/file/executable stored; idea text in `full_text_json.original_text` under QuotedTwinText envelope | ✅ |
| 6 | Thread page renders idea bubble + status bubble + Dad-reply bubbles; auth-gated; twin isolation correct | ✅ |
| 7 | Non-author twins redirected; Dad unrestricted; unauthenticated to login | ✅ |
| 8 | Dad-reply uses TWIN-layer language; no story IDs, Paperclip URLs, file paths, provider names | ✅ |
| 9 | Dad `/portal/ideas/all/` all-family view; `[data-portal-ideas="all"]`; twins redirected away | ✅ |
| 10 | Dad reply POST creates `thread_messages` row; updates `threads.status` to `"replied"`; twins blocked | ✅ |
| 11 | Executable-boundary guard fires; stores as `status: "draft"`; twin-safe message; no forward to agent/model | ✅ |
| 12 | Paperclip bridge as non-executing spec stub only; no live HTTP call from browser input | ✅ |
| 13 | Single `portal.db`; no second DB, generic envelope, Paperclip issue, provider/model, deploy, Roblox runtime | ✅ |
| 14 | Focused verification umbrella named in `tests/test_portal_ideas.py` covering all paths | ✅ |

### Key Strengths

- QuotedTwinText envelope fully specified (5 fields) with JS object shape, insert/read patterns in Dev Notes ✅
- Executable boundary guard explicitly reuses P2-2 command guard pattern ✅
- Deferred Paperclip stub has exact spec comment block with `// DEFERRED (PORTAL-P3-C7)` label and `Do NOT un-comment` instruction ✅
- Twin cross-thread isolation: resolve `thread.actor_id` before render; redirect (not 404) for non-authors ✅
- TWIN-layer exclusions comprehensive: 14-string positive copy list + explicit DO NOT RENDER list ✅
- All dependency commit hashes correct and consistent with sprint-status.yaml ✅

### Findings (neither blocks ready-for-dev)

**F1 — Low severity:** AC7 thread-isolation rule is ambiguous for Dad-mediated posts. When Dad posts on behalf of Khalil (`actor_id: "dad"`, `subject_twin_id: "khalil"`), AC7's `actor_id` check would prevent Khalil from reading the thread. Developer should document the branch taken (check `subject_twin_id` in isolation logic, or treat Dad-mediated threads as Dad-only until shared) consistent with the P3-1/P3-2 "Developer documents the branch taken" pattern.

**F2 — Low severity:** No Verification Command includes a reachability smoke test for `/portal/threads/{id}` (logged-out → redirect, not 404). The auth-gating test for `/portal/ideas/` (AC1) covers the inbox, but the thread route is checked only via positive render tests. Recommend adding an unauthenticated probe for the thread route.

### Scope Boundary

Story correctly contains Gate C gap C6 only. C7 async polling deferred (spec stub only). P3-1 decisions and P3-2 screenshots untouched. `/portal/prompts/new` must remain intact per explicit exclusions.

Next: ScrumMaster may flip [ROB-305](/ROB/issues/ROB-305) to `ready-for-dev` and route Developer to implement [PORTAL-P3-3](/ROB/issues/ROB-305).

## Done — PORTAL-P3-3 story file authored

Story artifact written to `_bmad-output/implementation-artifacts/PORTAL-P3-3.md`.

### What the story covers

- **Idea inbox** at `/portal/ideas/` — identity-scoped list of posted ideas, with `[data-portal-ideas="inbox"]` and `[data-idea-card]` selectors
- **Post form** at `/portal/ideas/new` — free-text idea field, optional title, Dad-mediated `subject_twin_id` selector, CSRF token, executable-boundary guard
- **Thread read page** at `/portal/threads/{id}` — original idea bubble + `awaiting-reply` status bubble + Dad-reply bubbles; twin cross-thread isolation enforced
- **Dad all-ideas view** at `/portal/ideas/all/` — all family threads sorted by `updated_at DESC`; Khalil/Kareem redirected away
- **Dad reply path** — `POST /portal/threads/{id}/reply` creates a new `thread_messages` row; twins blocked from this path
- **New sqlite tables**: `threads` + `thread_messages` in the same `portal.db` as decisions, votes, and screenshots; no second database
- **QuotedTwinText envelope** on every raw twin text field; `instruction_boundary: "data-only-not-instructions"` on all rows carrying twin input
- **Non-executing Paperclip spec stub** labelled `// DEFERRED (PORTAL-P3-C7)` — no live Paperclip API call is made

### Deferred (per sprint plan scope)

- Browser-created Paperclip issue creation (C6 Paperclip bridge)
- Async Paperclip comment ingestion / `/portal/api/sync` polling (C7 async polling)

### 14 acceptance criteria — key highlights

- AC 4/5: `threads` row + initial `thread_messages` system row; `QuotedTwinText` envelope verified
- AC 6/7: thread read page renders idea + status bubble; twin cross-thread isolation + Dad open access
- AC 11: executable-boundary guard stores draft, does not redirect to thread
- AC 12: Paperclip bridge present only as non-executing spec stub, not executed
- AC 13: no second database, no provider/model, no free chat, no deploy, no Roblox runtime

### Status

Story artifact is in `created` status. Do **not** flip to `ready-for-dev` — CodeReviewer story-file sanity check in a separate issue gates the flip per the [Portal Sprint P-3 plan](/ROB/issues/ROB-293).